I heard of an appeal during the Haspel vs Onomatopeia match about a non alerted bid.
I would like to know the data of the problem (segment ? board ? etc...).
TIA
Erkson
Page 1 of 1
? Match Haspel-Onomatopeia : appeal
#2
Posted 2003-September-10, 05:46
It was the last board (8th) of the 1st segment:
http://bbo.bridgebase.com:81/perl/history....32&p=2003-09-09
Played at 19:3
None vulnerable
North: KQ-A5-QJ32-J65432
East: 7653-KQJ-954-KQT
South: 82-9876-AKT86-97
West: AJT94-T432-7-A85
The bidding was:
South West North East
pass pass 1d pass
3d pass pass pass
The 3d bid 6-9 with 4+ diamonds was not alerted nor asked at the table.
I wasn't playing at tha table but apparently west said that she was going to bid over a weak 3d and passed assuming it was a limit bid.
http://bbo.bridgebase.com:81/perl/history....32&p=2003-09-09
Played at 19:3
None vulnerable
North: KQ-A5-QJ32-J65432
East: 7653-KQJ-954-KQT
South: 82-9876-AKT86-97
West: AJT94-T432-7-A85
The bidding was:
South West North East
pass pass 1d pass
3d pass pass pass
The 3d bid 6-9 with 4+ diamonds was not alerted nor asked at the table.
I wasn't playing at tha table but apparently west said that she was going to bid over a weak 3d and passed assuming it was a limit bid.
The legend of the black octogon.
#3
Posted 2003-September-10, 05:50
Many thanks, Luis, for the information, and congratulations for your team's victory.
Regards.
Erkson
Regards.
Erkson
#4
Posted 2003-September-10, 06:05
Hi Erkson & Luis!
I think it was a bug in BBO software. As you can see from myhands - carlosp, it WAS alerted! Also can download or open temporary from:
http://mnet.bg/~mfn/3DCarlos.lin
Misho
I think it was a bug in BBO software. As you can see from myhands - carlosp, it WAS alerted! Also can download or open temporary from:
http://mnet.bg/~mfn/3DCarlos.lin
Misho
MishoVnBg
#5
Posted 2003-September-10, 06:32
The bridge movie shows the Alert regardless of when the alert was actually made. So the hand record cannot, in this instance, tell you when
the alert was made.
Not that any of this is necc. in dispute, of course
the alert was made.
Not that any of this is necc. in dispute, of course
#6
Posted 2003-September-10, 08:46
As usual, the problem stems from an all too familar problem in the BBO. Neither team appeared to have bothered to have filled out a convention card.
After 7 round of knockout play, you would have thought these established partnerships would have had one (if I overlooked a convention card for one pair, I semi-apologize, but the problem in the tournment was very obvious). Clearly the rules for these type of events will have to be admended in the future to require a completed BBO Convention card by ALL PARTNERSHIPS.
The infraction at the table was clear. There was no alert. The response by carlosp to susie and dank's inquiry (hehehe) about the failure to alert was, well, not in the best spirit, as he questioned how dank knew what susieq asked him in private (the private interchange was more or less obvious to all from the bidding and the nature of the public interchange that was also taking place). So rather than being about bridge, the table, which now had all the kibitizer as the first table was finished, was witnessed by tons of people. I think the players should just note the controversy, for later ruling by the juror, and then play on. Fortunately, while the conditions of contest were very tense, and the infraction potentially might play a major role in the outcome of the match, the players mantained their cool, and the play (eventually) continued. All of this could/would have been avoid with a convention card.
Ben
After 7 round of knockout play, you would have thought these established partnerships would have had one (if I overlooked a convention card for one pair, I semi-apologize, but the problem in the tournment was very obvious). Clearly the rules for these type of events will have to be admended in the future to require a completed BBO Convention card by ALL PARTNERSHIPS.
The infraction at the table was clear. There was no alert. The response by carlosp to susie and dank's inquiry (hehehe) about the failure to alert was, well, not in the best spirit, as he questioned how dank knew what susieq asked him in private (the private interchange was more or less obvious to all from the bidding and the nature of the public interchange that was also taking place). So rather than being about bridge, the table, which now had all the kibitizer as the first table was finished, was witnessed by tons of people. I think the players should just note the controversy, for later ruling by the juror, and then play on. Fortunately, while the conditions of contest were very tense, and the infraction potentially might play a major role in the outcome of the match, the players mantained their cool, and the play (eventually) continued. All of this could/would have been avoid with a convention card.
Ben
--Ben--
#7
Posted 2003-September-10, 09:45
I did have a convention card with my pd :-)
About this incident I won't comment because I'm biased and because I don't like what both sides did at the table.
About this incident I won't comment because I'm biased and because I don't like what both sides did at the table.
The legend of the black octogon.
Page 1 of 1

Help
