Italian Marking
#1
Posted 2026-November-17, 04:23
Note that we are on a club level.
#2
Posted 2026-November-17, 05:03
Odd - encourage
Even - high (8,6) higher ranking suit
Even - low (4,2) lower ranking suit
This is different from Lavinthal in that there is no neutral discard.
#3
Posted 2026-November-17, 05:35
#4
Posted 2026-November-17, 08:12
The problem arises when you hold no odd cards in the suit or suits you wish to show a liking for and no even cards in the suit or suits where you’d like to discourage. The result, for many, is that the discard is made in tempo when you have the ‘right’ spots and made noticeably slower when you don’t. One doesn’t need to be a genius to figure out that a slowly chosen card may not convey the same message as one played in tempo.
#5
Posted 2026-November-17, 09:49
#6
Posted 2026-November-17, 10:15
The potential for abuse of tempo is there, just as it is in any of the many situations in bridge where you do not have a perfect call or card available, or simply wish to add extra information. In practice I have rarely seen tempo abused in discarding, except unknowingly by beginners. Bidding, leading and following suit are more problematic.
#7
Posted 2026-November-17, 10:54
#8
Posted 2026-November-17, 12:08
mga010, on 2026-November-17, 09:49, said:
Watch good players. They tend not to signal very much. I love playing against players who think signalling honestly is close to mandatory. They make my life far easier than it should be. Personally, I only give count if I think partner will benefit from it as much as or more than declarer. Also, giving false signals can be extremely useful against good but not WC declarers. Most club level players don’t know how to use the opponents’ carding against them but once they begin to do so, they can sometimes be misled. You have to pick your spots and it helps if partner understands that you might be doing it.
My favourite story on this is declaring against Passell and Wold. The key was taking 4 tricks with Qxx opposite AK10x. Both defenders signalled an odd number of cards in the suit so I played for Jxxx onside, successfully. Good players don’t tell declarer how to play the hand. I did feel mildly insulted, lol.
#9
Posted 2026-November-18, 04:39
mikeh, on 2026-November-17, 12:08, said:
Nice story. Game theory often requires doing things with randomness. See e.g. the problem of restricted choice. Unfortunately, that level of refinement does not apply to where I play. My club never heard of length markings.
#10
Posted 2026-November-18, 13:29
mga010, on 2026-November-18, 04:39, said:
#11
Posted Yesterday, 05:07
DavidKok, on 2026-November-18, 13:29, said:
No problem with nitpicking :-) Makes one think harder about ones arguments. My idea was that always fooling the declarer is just as bad as never fooling him. Both exhibit the distribution. Consequently, you should sometimes fool, depending on the level of the declarer, and randomly. Personally, I'd think that agreeing on markings only where they are sure to matter is the best idea.
#12
Posted Yesterday, 09:50
mga010, on 2026-November-19, 05:07, said:
It's not always easy to tell whether signals will help declarer more than partner. The default assumption is usually that you want to help partner.
There are some obvious counterexamples. The best is when one of you is nearly broke and the other has most of the defensive strength. The strong one will be most active on defense, and they usually need to be able to infer declarer's shape. So the weak hand should give honest count, while the strong hand doesn't need to signal at all. Declarer often doesn't know which is which (unless the auction gave this away), so they can't easily decode the signals.
#13
Posted Yesterday, 12:21
mga010, on 2026-November-19, 05:07, said:
Look at this hand:
https://www.bridgeba...-a-play-lesson/
I needed a count signal at trick 5 so that I could count out declarer's hand at trick 8 to figure out what to lead. (I did not get the correct count signal; I should've gotten it right anyway because the lead at trick 7 made the count unambiguous, but I didn't (and there are holdings where the lead at trick 7 would not have been clear).)
#14
Posted Yesterday, 16:16
mikeh, on 2026-November-17, 12:08, said:
My favourite story on this is declaring against Passell and Wold. The key was taking 4 tricks with Qxx opposite AK10x. Both defenders signalled an odd number of cards in the suit so I played for Jxxx onside, successfully. Good players don’t tell declarer how to play the hand. I did feel mildly insulted, lol.
Mike, when you say, "They tend not to signal very much and, personally, I only give count if I think partner will benefit from it,"—if I understand correctly, you are saying experts don't often signal because it isn't necessary, and both you and your partner will know when it actually matters.
If you are neither signaling nor false carding to trap declarer, how do you decide which spot cards to play?
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)

Help
