Keri again (question)
#1
Posted 2005-February-18, 09:27
For example
x
KXXXX
AJXX
xxx
1NT-2C-2S-P
What is the logic behind the 2M response to 2c being min, as i see it the structure will work a little better when 2M is max.
#2
Posted 2005-February-18, 10:01
Flame, on Feb 18 2005, 10:27 AM, said:
For example
x
KXXXX
AJXX
xxx
1NT-2C-2S-P
What is the logic behind the 2M response to 2c being min, as i see it the structure will work a little better when 2M is max.
Isn't responder allowed to rebid 2N with that hand?
If you play the direct 2M as maximum, won't you be faced with a similar problem when it goes 1N-2♣-2♦-2♥-2♠ (opener holding a 5233 minimum)? If opener is 53 in the majors and passes 2♥, you could play in a 43 heart fit instead of a 53 spade fit.
#3
Posted 2005-February-18, 10:20
TimG, on Feb 18 2005, 11:01 AM, said:
If you play the direct 2M as maximum, won't you be faced with a similar problem when it goes 1N-2♣-2♦-2♥-2♠ (opener holding a 5233 minimum)? If opener is 53 in the majors and passes 2♥, you could play in a 43 heart fit instead of a 53 spade fit.
No atleast not on the version presented on the forum where 2nt is non natural, asking for doublton.
you are right about that problem.
#4
Posted 2005-February-21, 10:35
1NT 2C
2M
as a MIN. The point is if you have a min and bid 2D, then pard might make an invitational bid and you have to refuse it and miss a 5-3 major suit fit which might even be worth game. Example: if you play 2M as max...
1NT 2C
2D 3C
pass?
Axx.......xx
AKxxx...xxx
Axx.......xx
xx.........AQxxxx
whereas if you play 2M as min, it will be
1NT 2C
2H 4H
#5
Posted 2005-February-21, 10:49
1NT 2C
2H Pass
How good is this game? If trumps are 4-1 you go down. If the K of clubs is offside you go down. If clubs are 4-1 you go down.
#6
Posted 2005-February-21, 10:53
#7
Posted 2005-February-21, 15:56
1nt-2c-2d-2nt as GF stayman or
1NT-2S as the GF stayman.
It seems to be more or less the same
In another version i have on keri, after 1nt-2c-2d-2nt asks opener to show his hand rather then bid 3c for responder to show his, this have a little space adv (open can show 4-4 and 5 card minor) and also the advatage of beeing much simpler then normal old keri 2NT, but give info about opener's hand.
One last thing i thought of one thing that could be an advantage over keri, playing
1nt-2c
2d-2NT as invite with 6 card minor, partner will bid 3D=accept if you have clubs, 3H=accept both(or use 3H/3S/3NT for stopers or something), or else 3c.
This will save some space, the small price is giving own a little more info about opener hand sometimes, i think its an improvment.
#8
Posted 2005-February-21, 16:13
Flame, on Feb 21 2005, 03:56 PM, said:
1nt-2c-2d-2nt as GF stayman or
1NT-2S as the GF stayman.
It seems to be more or less the same
In another version i have on keri, after 1nt-2c-2d-2nt asks opener to show his hand rather then bid 3c for responder to show his, this have a little space adv (open can show 4-4 and 5 card minor) and also the advatage of beeing much simpler then normal old keri 2NT, but give info about opener's hand.
One last thing i thought of one thing that could be an advantage over keri, playing
1nt-2c
2d-2NT as invite with 6 card minor, partner will bid 3D=accept if you have clubs, 3H=accept both(or use 3H/3S/3NT for stopers or something), or else 3c.
This will save some space, the small price is giving own a little more info about opener hand sometimes, i think its an improvment.
i still don't understand why not just play puppet stayman... only bid 2C if you're invitational *or* if you plan on passing whatever opener rebids... the 2D gf stayman works very well
on the hand whereagles posted:
Axx.......xx
AKxxx...xxx
Axx.......xx
xx.........AQxxxx
as responder (playing 12-15 nt) i'm not sure i'd bid 2c invitational... yeah opener does have 7 controls with a max, but that's this time... if anything i'd bid 2nt, which relays to 3c pass/correct
#9
Posted 2005-February-21, 16:44
luke warm, on Feb 21 2005, 05:13 PM, said:
Flame, on Feb 21 2005, 03:56 PM, said:
1nt-2c-2d-2nt as GF stayman or
1NT-2S as the GF stayman.
It seems to be more or less the same
In another version i have on keri, after 1nt-2c-2d-2nt asks opener to show his hand rather then bid 3c for responder to show his, this have a little space adv (open can show 4-4 and 5 card minor) and also the advatage of beeing much simpler then normal old keri 2NT, but give info about opener's hand.
One last thing i thought of one thing that could be an advantage over keri, playing
1nt-2c
2d-2NT as invite with 6 card minor, partner will bid 3D=accept if you have clubs, 3H=accept both(or use 3H/3S/3NT for stopers or something), or else 3c.
This will save some space, the small price is giving own a little more info about opener hand sometimes, i think its an improvment.
i still don't understand why not just play puppet stayman... only bid 2C if you're invitational *or* if you plan on passing whatever opener rebids... the 2D gf stayman works very well
on the hand whereagles posted:
Axx.......xx
AKxxx...xxx
Axx.......xx
xx.........AQxxxx
as responder (playing 12-15 nt) i'm not sure i'd bid 2c invitational... yeah opener does have 7 controls with a max, but that's this time... if anything i'd bid 2nt, which relays to 3c pass/correct
Keri has some advantage over stayman like systems. The biggest one is opener doesnt show his hand.
The most common situation over 1NT is responder having inv strengh with 4 card amjor while opener doesnt have this 4 card major.
In non keri system opener will show his 4 card or lack of 4 card major before they settle down in 2/3 NT. In keri responder will show his 4 card while opener will not show his hand.
There are other advantage like playing 2M on 4-3 where the rest of the field will play 2NT, which as i see it is little better. Anoter nice one is the 5-3 major fit inv strengh opposite minimum opening which we will play at the 2 level while you will play at the 3 level.
I bet there are disadvantage too, but those who play keri say it works out fine for them. (those 4-3 2M are cool)
#10
Posted 2005-February-21, 17:05
Quote
not always, the way i play.. 2C asks for a 5 card major, else 2D.. if 2D:
2H denies 4 hearts and *maybe* has 4 spades (used to invite 2NT)
2S denies 4 spades and guarantees 4 hearts
Quote
yes, this can be a problem (assuming responder has the 5 card major - no prob if it's opener, he just bids it over 2C)
#11
Posted 2005-February-21, 17:46
But keri has 2d for transfer which i like in my system.
#12
Posted 2005-February-21, 18:03
#13
Posted 2005-February-21, 18:33
but dammit i sure do like the 2d game force

Help
