1D opening playing a mini-NT
#1
Posted 2005-February-15, 16:39
In particular, what strength should 1♦:1NT and 1♦:2♣ show, and what should opener rebid after 1♦:1NT with a balanced hand? Or, is it completely impossible to play natural responses here? What do people think?
#2
Posted 2005-February-15, 17:03
An interesting set of responses is that used by von Arnim and Auken.
1D 1H = Natural or beginning of an invit + relay
Now as a start for you
1S = both ms
1N = flat
2C = Ds min
2D = D max
Over these, d bids are nnf, bids at three level are GF
Others over 1D
1S = nat forcing
1N = 7-11
2C = nnf
2D = 5+D, 7-10
Others you can probably work out for yourself
#3
Posted 2005-February-15, 18:01
We have fared quite well with our 11-15 1NT opening denying a 4-card major. No need for Stayman, so 2C is free for a second form of invitation (can't have all invitational hands bid 2NT opposite such a wide range), and with all the balanced hands containing a 4-card major, just open 1D. The thing is to not bother too much about diamonds (or clubs, for that matter) with your 1D opener, try to find a 4-4 major fit first, and only if that fails should you start worrying about the minors. For instance, in our system, 1D-1H-2C shows 5+ clubs, but also exactly 4 spades! because we want to establish once and for all whether there is a 4-4 major suit fit.
It's possible to get great results with just a bit of science. Here's what we bid last week:
1D (11-15 nebulous) - 1H (0+ points, 4+ hearts)
2S (3=0=5=5 shape) - 6C (OK, maybe a bit more than 0 points)
Short and sweet, and making exactly 12 tricks.
-- Bertrand Russell
#4
Posted 2005-February-15, 22:08
1♣ = 15+ any
1♦ = 10-15, no 5+M (0+♦)
1M = 10-15, 5+M
1NT = 10-12 bal, no 5M
higher openings are used for preemptive bidding
To be honest, theoreticly the 1♦ opening is a weak spot, but in practice it works out just fine. It's not (semi)natural at all, it's just a garbage-bid.
Our response scheme over 1♦ is as follows:
1♥ = 4+♥ (can have longer m) OR inv+ relay
1♠ = 4+♠, can have longer m
1NT = NF, no 4 card M, may be semi-balanced
2m = (5)6+m, NF
2M = preemptive
2NT = 55+m, no invitational values
3m = good suit, invitational for 3NT
3M = preemptive
3NT = to play
After 1♦-1♥ we have a full relay scheme (as after any limited opening).
#5
Posted 2005-February-15, 23:07
david_c, on Feb 15 2005, 10:39 PM, said:
In particular, what strength should 1♦:1NT and 1♦:2♣ show, and what should opener rebid after 1♦:1NT with a balanced hand? Or, is it completely impossible to play natural responses here? What do people think?
If you want something simple (which you probably don't!) then I would say whatever your NT opening,
1♦:1NT = to play opposite balanced range
1♦:2♣ = nat GF opposite balanced range, so usually 10+
The 1♦ opener is such that you should be less keen to open it on unbalanced minimums than when playing strong NT, which has the side effect that you can make 1♦:2♣ promise another bid if you so desire - then you could keep your old meanings for opener's rebid (2♦ = 5+♦, other 2 level bids deny 5♦).
#6
Posted 2005-February-16, 03:19
#7
Posted 2005-February-16, 04:17
whereagles, on Feb 16 2005, 09:19 AM, said:
Could you post your full relay structure ?
I am particularly interested to the sequences where opener has 3 or 4H and needs to resolve whether there is H fit or not, either for:
- signing off in partscore if the relayer has really H and a weak hand
- low level slam investigation in H when the H fit is found.
Thanks !
#8
Posted 2005-February-16, 04:37
1) Balanced, no major OR
2) 5+ in a minor (C or D)
Me and a friend designed a full scheme of responses to this particular nebulous 1D, which includes the 1D 1H "semi-relay". However the gagdetry only works for this wierd kind of 1D opening.
I can post the whole thing here if you want. I'm not sure it will help you much, though it might be that you can pick an idea or two out of it.
In any case, my experience is that the 1D 1H relay works very well after nebulous 1D openings, so it's definitely something the serious precision player should think a bit on.
#9
Posted 2005-February-16, 05:02
whereagles, on Feb 16 2005, 10:37 AM, said:
I have the Viking precision Club book where they suggest the 1H relay as "either natural or GF".
The idea is nice, but the developments can be cumbersome- unless one wants to use the full-relay followup to 1H (which is the VikingClub scheme).
For example:
1D:1H(nat or generic GF)
2H(natural 4+)
Now there is a need to:
- force game WITH 4 H
- force game with 3 card support in H
- force game with short H
- game try with 4H
- game try with 5H
Any EASY suggestion is most welcome (EASY = if you want to relay, the relay should last only 1 round of bidding
#10
Posted 2005-February-16, 05:04
The_Hog, on Feb 15 2005, 11:03 PM, said:
An interesting set of responses is that used by von Arnim and Auken.
1D 1H = Natural or beginning of an invit + relay
Now as a start for you
1S = both ms
1N = flat
After
1D:1H(nat or relay with good hand)
1NT
if responder is weak with 4H, can't you lose many 44 heart partscores ?
#11
Posted 2005-February-16, 07:09
Just bid natural!
1♠ = 4♠
1N = balanced no 4M, i.e 33(43), (32)44 or 22(54) or 5m332
2♣ = minors
2♦ = 6+♦
2♥ = 4♥
Now after 1♦ - 1♥ - 2♥
Now the next bid (2♠) asks for a singleton, 3m is natural and game forcing.
Responses to 2♠:
2NT = NO singleton
3♣ = ♣ singleton
3♦ = ♦ singleton
3♥ = ♠ singleton
You still have 2NT left as general game try, after which partner may sign off or bid "values" in a minor.
If you have a game try there is no need to tell partner if you have 4 or 5 hearts. You need to know what HE has. If you have 3-card support for partner and GF you can also use one of the tools above and then decide if 4♥ is a good idea or not.
#12
Posted 2005-February-16, 07:17
Gerben47, on Feb 16 2005, 01:09 PM, said:
Now the next bid (2♠) asks for a singleton, 3m is natural and game forcing.
If you have 3-card support for partner and GF you can also use one of the tools above and then decide if 4♥ is a good idea or not.
That's my point:
when I have 3 card support as opener I need to know whether pard has a 5 bagger or NO hearts at all.
after
1♦ - 1♥ - 2♥-?
Responder needs a tool to force to game without confusing his pard:
opener in the followup will NEED to know whether they are in an auction with hearts agreed or not.
So, responder must have asking tools but he needs to let opener know *below the 3NT level* whether hearts are agreed or not.
One reason for this is that in my pship we play SERIOUS 3NT with major fit agreed.
#13
Posted 2005-February-16, 07:18
Chamaco, on Feb 16 2005, 09:04 PM, said:
The_Hog, on Feb 15 2005, 11:03 PM, said:
An interesting set of responses is that used by von Arnim and Auken.
1D 1H = Natural or beginning of an invit + relay
Now as a start for you
1S = both ms
1N = flat
After
1D:1H(nat or relay with good hand)
1NT
if responder is weak with 4H, can't you lose many 44 heart partscores ?
No Mauro, as we open with 4 card Majors, opener will open 1H with a weak hand not in the NT range. We only lose a 4-4 H ft if opener opens 1N and responder does not have the strength to move - same as in any system.
#14
Posted 2005-February-16, 07:19
The_Hog, on Feb 16 2005, 01:18 PM, said:
Oh ok, sorry, I was concentrated on the Precision-type nebulous diamond
#15
Posted 2005-February-16, 16:59
#16
Posted 2005-February-17, 05:35
luke warm, on Feb 16 2005, 11:59 PM, said:
Wouldn't it be better if we all just played Acol? Well, actually, no.
Yes you do need to spend a bit of time getting your 1D response structure straight. But you have to put effort into, say, your 1C response structure as well, so...
And no, it doesn't cause a lot of trouble.
-- Bertrand Russell
#17
Posted 2005-February-17, 06:05
1H 1NT (relay)
2C = 4 hearts only
2D + = 5+ hearts, as before.
If we only open 4 card majors with balanced hands then this shouldn't be too hard to impliment
Suggestions would be welcome for a relay structure that incorporates balanced hands here after 1H 1NT 2C 2D
Mark (Dave's partner)
#18
Posted 2005-February-17, 10:43
mgoetze, on Feb 17 2005, 05:35 AM, said:
luke warm, on Feb 16 2005, 11:59 PM, said:
Wouldn't it be better if we all just played Acol? Well, actually, no.
Yes you do need to spend a bit of time getting your 1D response structure straight. But you have to put effort into, say, your 1C response structure as well, so...
And no, it doesn't cause a lot of trouble.
acol hasn't even entered the discussion... the ones for whom 1D promises 4+, who have posted so far, play a strong 1C system

Help
