I am keen on opening 4 card majors in a strong club context. There are definite benefits from looking for some 4-3 fits with a ruffing value in the short trump hand, making the opps guess when to balance. However, 5-4 fits (5 with opener, 4 with responder) become hard to judge - opener thinks it may be a 5-3, responder thinks it may be a 4-4. It also makes penalty doubles harder to find - the more cards you have in your fit, the more likely the opps are to make their contract. MOSCITO recommends immediately supporting to the 3 level with 4 card support, but this can lead to taking a minus score when the hand belonged to us at the 2 level. To solve this problem, I think the hands with exactly 5 cards in the major should find a different opening bid.
What responses would work well opposite a 1M opener showing either 4 cards ( probably 11-13 bal or 11-15 with a longer minor) or 6+ cards? My first idea is this...
In response to 1♠:
1N NF. Then pass = bal, 2m = 5m4♠, 2♥ = max with 6♠, 2♠ = nat min, 3m = 6m4♠ max.
2♣ GF relay. 2♦=SS, 2♥=4♠5+♣, 2♠=bal, 2N+ = 4♠5+♦
2♦ and 2♥ natural INV
Over 1♥ it seems Kaplan Inversion would not work, as a 2443 wouldn't have a bid after 1♥:1N. So 1♥:1♠ should be nat F1, with others as above.
The relays leave out 6M4m hands, which could be a problem. Is there a decent alternative to relays? 2/1 would seem to be worthy of consideration, but 1♠:2♥ would be quite preemptive - presumably 2♠ = 6+, 2N = bal, 3m = 5m4M? So reversing could not show extras.
This leaves hands with a 5 card major to sort out. One option is to open them at the 2 level (probably 2♣ = both majors, 2M = 5M4+m). This would leave 1♦ as unbal without a 4 card major (if playing a 12-15 NT) or just showing no 4 card major, 11-13 bal or 11-15 unbal (what responses did Moscito use when it had a similar opening?)
Another option would be to open 1♦ on all hands with a 5 card major. Any ideas on responses to this? Misho mentioned a while back that this was part of a strong pass system, any ideas what that system is called? Maybe it would be better to make it promise a 2 suiter with a 5+major, opening 5M332s 1M and treating them as 4 cards from then on. It may also be worth trying to take the major 2 suiters out of the opening, making it easier to find our fit (if we open 1♦ with 5♥ and 1♠, it is fairly unlikely that partner will have less ♠ than ♥, so if we have a ♥ fit we are likely to find it. If we have 5♥ and 4♠, there is a much greater chance of a fit being buried). However 2♣ and 2♦ would seem to be needed as natural, 6m or 5-4 minors, so it seems unlikely that this would work.
Any suggestions or comments?
TIA

Help
