1♣-1♠-1NT-2♦
?
What the meaning of the following bids:
2♥
D
2NT
3♣
Page 1 of 1
Polish club question
#2
Posted 2004-October-29, 17:48
Don't really exist as 1N is limited to 12-14.
Flame I'd say that each of these shows a D fit of various types - the precise meaning is up to you. Perhaps the suits show a max hand and a feature, and 2N shows good 4 card support flattish.
To some extent the answer depends on whether you open 1C or 1D on a a flat hand with 4D
Flame I'd say that each of these shows a D fit of various types - the precise meaning is up to you. Perhaps the suits show a max hand and a feature, and 2N shows good 4 card support flattish.
To some extent the answer depends on whether you open 1C or 1D on a a flat hand with 4D
"The King of Hearts a broadsword bears, the Queen of Hearts a rose." W. H. Auden.
#3
Posted 2004-October-29, 18:04
Flame, on Oct 30 2004, 01:41 AM, said:
1♣-1♠-1NT-2♦
?
What the meaning of the following bids:
2♥
D
2NT
3♣
?
What the meaning of the following bids:
2♥
D
2NT
3♣
the bidding is confusing to me... who's bidding what? is this all 4 people bidding? it must be since one of your questions concerned 'double' heheh
"Paul Krugman is a stupid person's idea of what a smart person sounds like." Newt Gingrich (paraphrased)
#4
Posted 2004-October-29, 18:08
I assumed it was
1C 1S
1N 2D
?
?
If it is
1C (1S) 1N (2D)
Then
2H = 19+ with H
X = 4H, 5+C 16+
2N = 19+ forcing
3C = 16+ C forcing
1C 1S
1N 2D
?
?
If it is
1C (1S) 1N (2D)
Then
2H = 19+ with H
X = 4H, 5+C 16+
2N = 19+ forcing
3C = 16+ C forcing
"The King of Hearts a broadsword bears, the Queen of Hearts a rose." W. H. Auden.
#5
Posted 2004-October-29, 18:55
The_Hog, on Oct 30 2004, 02:08 AM, said:
I assumed it was
1C 1S
1N 2D
?
?
If it is
1C (1S) 1N (2D)
Then
2H = 19+ with H
X = 4H, 5+C 16+
2N = 19+ forcing
3C = 16+ C forcing
1C 1S
1N 2D
?
?
If it is
1C (1S) 1N (2D)
Then
2H = 19+ with H
X = 4H, 5+C 16+
2N = 19+ forcing
3C = 16+ C forcing
on the first, with no interference, 2d is game forcing checkback so
2h=4 pcs
2nt=2 spades and 3 hearts
3c=hell i don't know.. maybe 2236 or 2326, but makes the 1nt rebid kinda funky
if 1c (1s) 1n (2d) then i'm guessing
2h=4+ with longer clubs, 16+
x=with your nt bid and my hand, it's ours... do something wise
2n=18, 19 with stoppers
3c=probably 7, maybe 6 clubs and 15ish-17ish
"Paul Krugman is a stupid person's idea of what a smart person sounds like." Newt Gingrich (paraphrased)
#6
Posted 2004-October-29, 19:49
No Jimmy, Flame is talking about Polish Club. Bidding is quite different to SA or 2/1.
Most play only 1 version of checkback - 2C
Most play only 1 version of checkback - 2C
"The King of Hearts a broadsword bears, the Queen of Hearts a rose." W. H. Auden.
#7
Posted 2004-October-29, 21:49
oh hell, you're right... helps to read the topic eh?
"Paul Krugman is a stupid person's idea of what a smart person sounds like." Newt Gingrich (paraphrased)
#8
Posted 2004-October-29, 22:54
The_Hog, on Oct 29 2004, 07:08 PM, said:
If it is
1C (1S) 1N (2D)
Then
2H = 19+ with H
X = 4H, 5+C 16+
2N = 19+ forcing
3C = 16+ C forcing
1C (1S) 1N (2D)
Then
2H = 19+ with H
X = 4H, 5+C 16+
2N = 19+ forcing
3C = 16+ C forcing
thx this is what i ment, sry for the confusion.
wasnt sure if 2h can be the 5-4 version which then leaves D for punishment.
Page 1 of 1

Help
