I'd like some advice on the following sequence, in a version of Precision.
The following assumes that over a 1C opener, responder bids :
- naturally the 5+ card longer suit (except 1D) holding 8+ hcp
- 1NT with a balanced 8-13
- 2NT with balanced 14+
- other bids with a 3-suiter
I am aware there are better schemes (e.g. different ranges for balanced hands, transfer responses, semipositive responses, etc etc), but, PLEASE, I'd like to keep the discussion on the validity of such scheme maybe in another thread.
In this thread, let's just live with the fact that 1C:2NT shows a 14+ balanced hand, and not discuss the alternatives.
We decided to use this basing it on the scheme given in the Berkowicz book "Precision today".
After
1C:2NT
He suggests that the bidding should be forcing to at least 4NT (natural) or 5 of a suit, (otherwise too little space left)
Furthermore, he suggests that opener bids now would be:
3C = Baron
3X = Support Asking Bids
However he does not deal in much detail with this sequence.
So, after reading books by Jannersten, Wei, Garozzo-Belladonna, and more, I thought a decent scheme would be:
Question 1, 1C:2NT:3C =
option a
Baron. However, I am not very comfortable with Baron, in the sequences where I'd like to agree a suit and later use RKCB.
E.g.
1C:2NT
3C:3H
Now how do I discriminate: 1) RKCB with trump agreed; 2) Nirmal Ace ask; 3) trump agreement asking for a cue ?
You see, the point is to have a bid for "implicit agreement", keeping in mind I do not want to start cuebidding at the 5 level.
option b
Transfer responses to 1C:2NT:3C.
E.g.
3D = 4 hearts (may have 4 spades); if transfer is accepted, fit is assumed
3H = 4 spades, no 4 hearts
3S = 44 minor
3NT = 4333 with a minor
(Just an idea, suggestions for a smarter scheme welcome !
Not all the problems are solved, though
1C:2NT
3C:3D
3S*: ? * transfer not accepted., no 4 cd in Hearts, but 4 spades
Now which is the implicit agreements below 4 spades ?
Question 2, 1C:2NT:3X = Support asking bid
I like the scheme described by Jannersten in similar situations (not quite the same), where
1C:2NT:3X asks for support in the suit and controls
step 1 = no support, min range of controls
step 2= no support, max range of controls
step 3 = at least Hxx/xxxx, min range of controls
step 4 = at least Hxx/xxxx, max range of controls
If responder shows no support, then a new suit is another support asking bid in the second suit (useful when opener has a 2-suiter).
If responder shows support:
a ) new suit should be a control asking bid.
I have tried using this but sometimes it is very space consuming. Especially the fact that 2st step is 3rd round control, forces the biding to high level very quickly.
Do you suggest giving up the step showing 3rd round control, when the bidding is too high (and how high) ?
b ) after having shown support, repeating the trump suit should be "trump asking bid" (TAB), asking to clarify the holding in trumps.
However, I still feel more comfortable with RKCB sequences for checking trump quality (although I cannot check for Jacks).
Neither I nor pard can remember the TAB responses if we use a detailed scheme, and if we use a simplified scheme, we reach a level of description accuracy not better than RKCB.
Comments ?
( fobidden responses:
1) using a relay system is much better
2) if you had used another scheme of NT ranges you would not have this problem
3) try playing golf

Help
