Does anyone have any experience using MAFIA responses to a nebulous (2+) 1♦ opening in Precision?
I am trying to play Precision under ACBL GCC rules. See ACBL Convention Chart. Also, I would like to be as “natural” as possible and allow stopping at 2m.
Wei’s 30+ year old “Bidding Precisely 2” advocated MAFIA responses to 1♦ but didn’t call them that:
1M = 4+ long
1NT = 7-10 HCP balanced, no 4CM
2m = 4+ long, 10+ HCP, no 4CM
Jump shifts (2M, 3♣) = One suited, slammish
2NT = 16+ HCP, balanced, no 4CM
3NT = good 12 – 15 HCP, balanced, no 4CM
Presumably, I would add
3♦ = inverted, weak
3M = shortness in the bid M, at least 5-4 in the minors
Also, per suggestions from the Blue Club, 2M and 3♣ might be just a GF hand.
Responder’s rebids are “natural”. The only surprise is that a “fourth suit” is forcing only if it is a reverse or at the three level. Responder’s rebid of 2m was strictly canapé; with a 5CM and a 4-5 card minor, responder would rebid 2M.
Based on some simulations, I changed this so (1) opener will rebid 1NT with a singleton in responder’s major and 543 otherwise and (2) responder bids 2 of the 4+ minor. This is similar to what Blue Club does. For example:
1♦ 1M
1NT 2m = 5-4 either way in M and m, at most invitational.
Over 2m, opener should take another bid with a fit and a maximum.
The side effect of MAFIA responses is that opener’s distribution is not clear in sequences such as
1♦ 1M
1NT 3m = forcing and “natural”
Responder could be 5M332, 5M4xx, or 4M and 5+ in bid minor.
I do not know whether this ambiguity is a problem “in the real world,” which is why I am looking for any experience bidding this way.
If the problem needs to be fixed, do canape responses into the longer major fix this problem?
1♦ 2♣
2♦ 2M
would show 4 clubs and 5+ in bid M (might be 3 clubs only if 5332). As a result,
1♦ 1M
1NT 3m
shows a 4CM and a longer minor.
Thanks for any help you can provide.
Page 1 of 1
Nebulous Diamond and MAFIA responses
#2
Posted 2004-October-28, 21:18
Chris, I play Mafia responses to both Polish 1C and 1D openings.
A couple of points
1D 1M
1N 2C - keep this as checkback. Very important!!
2D - canape 4M long D, nf
2N - either inv with long C or D or GF with long C
Now 3C = doesnt like D, 3D does not like C, 3M = likes both, descriptive
3C - long C, to play
3D - gf with long D
With a 5 card M and 4m, simply rebid 2M over 1N
A couple of points
1D 1M
1N 2C - keep this as checkback. Very important!!
2D - canape 4M long D, nf
2N - either inv with long C or D or GF with long C
Now 3C = doesnt like D, 3D does not like C, 3M = likes both, descriptive
3C - long C, to play
3D - gf with long D
With a 5 card M and 4m, simply rebid 2M over 1N
"The King of Hearts a broadsword bears, the Queen of Hearts a rose." W. H. Auden.
Page 1 of 1

Help
