Note censored?
#41
Posted 2009-May-13, 12:07
The word 'should' always precedes an OPINION, Fred, not a 'statement of fact.'
#42
Posted 2009-May-13, 12:18
jonottawa, on May 13 2009, 12:23 PM, said:
I beg to differ.
When the obnoxious kibitzer crashes in the star-studded game, we innocent bystanders have to hear all sorts of foolishness.
Last week, the situation was so ridiculous, that the host threatened to close the game to kibitzer. So there, 600+ kibitzers cannot enjoy a game because the obnoxious attention seeker must have his say.
Of course the guy could come here to the water cooler and spew his venom, but that is not enough, because people read these things voluntarily. what he wants to annoy a lot of people who had 30 minutes to spare and wanted to learn and watch without listening to racist comments.
And there is not a thing I can do, the obnoxious one is already on the enemy list but public and table chat still appears.
I did not bother to complain, but kept the chat anyway.
the pity is that he is still allowed to log in!!!!
#43
Posted 2009-May-13, 12:42
jonottawa, on May 13 2009, 01:07 PM, said:
The word 'should' always precedes an OPINION, Fred, not a 'statement of fact.'
Says who? Quick research points to 3 common usages of 'should'. To give advice (You should not go to the beach without sunscreen), to express obligation (You should alert your conventional bids) [that seems to me the context in which you used it], or to express expectation (dinner should be ready by the time you get home from work). I can find no source at all that suggests 'should' implies an opinion in any of those cases. But it was pretty amusing that you stated "The word 'should' always precedes an OPINION, Fred, not a 'statement of fact.'" as a statement of fact, when it's in fact clearly wrong given that you said "always", and not necessarily right even if you didn't.
#44
Posted 2009-May-13, 13:13
cherdanno, on May 13 2009, 06:27 PM, said:
Yeah, if someone is an asshole I'd rather know it from his profile than experiencing it from his behavior after having invited him to a team match or whatever.
Then again, apparently some users think differently, and it's not like it's a big loss not being able to express my religious/political/sexual orientation on BBO, there are plenty of other places I can do so if I need.
#45
Posted 2009-May-13, 13:13
Rik
The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds the new discoveries, is not “Eureka!” (I found it!), but “That’s funny…” – Isaac Asimov
The only reason God did not put "Thou shalt mind thine own business" in the Ten Commandments was that He thought that it was too obvious to need stating. - Kenberg
#46
Posted 2009-May-13, 13:19
and
"In my opinion you should bid 3NT."
Do not mean the same thing to me.
Fred Gitelman
Bridge Base Inc.
www.bridgebase.com
#47
Posted 2009-May-13, 13:27
'Fred should not go to the beach without sunscreen' is not an opinion? Agreed, it borders on fact, but still, it is an opinion.
In bridge laws, 'should', 'shall' and 'must' all have different meanings that express varying degrees of obligation. Obviously I wasn't using the word in a legal context.
Your third example is a different usage of the word entirely.
I accept your quibble that I overgeneralized. But is that the best you can do? Let me rephrase and see if I can escape pedantic objection this time:
In the grammatical context and conversational environment in which I used it, 'you should' or 'it shouldn't be' always precedes an opinion.
#48
Posted 2009-May-13, 13:34
"You must use sunscreen" expresses an opinion or knowledge about an obligation.
"You should use sunscreen" expresses and opinion or knowledge about what is best for you, but acknowledges that it is your own choice, if you feel like burning your skin I can't force you not to.
It's not like one is based on knowledge and the other on opinion.
"Fred should allow me to write what I want in my profile" sounds to me like it acknowledges that Fred has no obligation to allow it, but does not necessarily acknowledge that my advice could be bad.
#49
Posted 2009-May-13, 13:48
jonottawa, on May 13 2009, 02:27 PM, said:
I don't know what you mean by asking if that's the best I can do.
If you mean my objection was petty, I think you opened yourself up to that by starting with LOL (meaning, I can't believe this idiot doesn't realize what I'm about to say). Obviously LOL will backfire if the LOLer is wrong!
If you mean my objection was pedantic, well again you are the one who focused on your use of that one particular word, so of course that was going to be dissected.
If you mean I should have more or better sources, I would counter that you don't seem to have any sources at all, just your own continued insistence.
Anyway I don't feel the need to do any better. I see four repliers to your posts on this topic, and they all believe you are wrong. At best that would mean that even if you are technically right then you are doing a poor job of communicating your sentiments. You might also realize that when you state your opinions (if that's what they are) so bluntly and rudely then it seems you are leaving open no possiblity that you might be wrong. That is not what an opinion is.
#50
Posted 2009-May-13, 14:04
Should I bid 3NT?
How should I play this hand?
What should BBO policy be on this issue?
These are all solicitations of opinion. You're quibbling for the sake of quibbling.
I'm so sick of fants.
#51
Posted 2009-May-13, 14:13
jonottawa, on May 13 2009, 12:23 PM, said:
That statement, you mean? Yes it looks like, especially in the context of the entire post, you believe what you say is fact.
#52
Posted 2009-May-13, 14:53
Just an opinion.
#53
Posted 2009-May-13, 14:57
Quote
The rules of this site, which are probably unread by the majority of the membership, clearly state playing on this site should be seen as a privilege, not as a right. If someone grants me the privilege of using his property, whatever it may be, e.g. "you may use my mountain cabin this weekend" I would feel compelled to abide by whatever rules come attached to that privilege, e. g. "but you can't take your dogs". Obviously you don't see it that way.
#54
Posted 2009-May-13, 15:12
How do you get from the quote you cited to the opinion you expressed?
Regardless, you're wrong. As I stated in my original post, Fred can make whatever rules he damn well pleases. And I can gripe about them, because it's a free country. And he can ignore my gripes or react to them or embrace them or whatever.
If your opinion is that no user of BBO should ever express any opinion about (or critical of) BBO policies simply because BBO is free, you're wrong about that too. Let me know if that's the case and I'd be happy to debate that point.
#55
Posted 2009-May-13, 15:16

Help
This topic is locked
