PassedOut, on Apr 25 2009, 08:38 PM, said:
Lobowolf, on Apr 23 2009, 06:16 PM, said:
I haven't formed a solid enough opinion of my own to want to persuade others on this particular topic.
My own inclination is that "Does it work?" is not a relevant big picture question, i.e. the end does not justify the means. However, particularly as weapons technology improves, I'm not completely certain about that.
I think these are all interesting and relevant questions, and that certainly one doesn't have to be right-wing or idiotic to raise the questions. As Alan Dershowitz has demonstrated.
My own inclination is that "Does it work?" is not a relevant big picture question, i.e. the end does not justify the means. However, particularly as weapons technology improves, I'm not completely certain about that.
I think these are all interesting and relevant questions, and that certainly one doesn't have to be right-wing or idiotic to raise the questions. As Alan Dershowitz has demonstrated.
Do you often give a lot of weight to the views expressed by Alan Dershowitz?
Most certainly not on any topic involving Arabs or Israel...

Help
