hrothgar, on Apr 23 2009, 03:17 PM, said:
I don't accept the premise of the question: These types of idiotic thought experiments are an attempt to distract people from the facts on the ground.
"Ticking Bomb" are great fodder for TV shows like "24". They don't occur in real life and they most certainly have NOTHING to do with the criminal abuses perpetrated by Cheney, Bush, and the like.
As you might expect, I disagree with most of your post.
First, the question is extremely useful from the perspective of analytical efficiency; when it's established that there would be opposition even if there was no doubt as to the efficacy, then there's no point in talking about whether or not it's an efficacious technique (which is a less certain question).
I also disagree that they "don't occur in real life." Sure, there was no literal "Ticking Bomb" on 9/11, but for all intents and purposes, there was. The plot was planned and set into motion in advance, and it was theoretically possible to thwart it. Discovering the principals, or the specifics of the plan before the planes took off would be, in principle, identical to finding and defusing the "ticking bomb."
I also think that the Op-Ed you cited doesn't support your critique of my question. Mr. Soufan goes to great lengths to make the case that the interrogation techniques in question are not useful. That editorial presupposes that the efficacy of the techniques may be a relevant criterion in their evaluation.
I was not trying to make a rhetorical point in asking the original question, though. As PassedOut is one of the more rational, nonpartisan WC contributors, I am particularly interested in his opinions on a variety of issues. I was not attempting "to distract people from the facts on the ground," but to get a better understanding of his position.
Thanks for answering, PO.
1. LSAT tutor for rent.
Call me Desdinova...Eternal Light
C. It's the nexus of the crisis and the origin of storms.
IV: ace 333: pot should be game, idk
e: "Maybe God remembered how cute you were as a carrot."