Drop Kx onside or pin the 10?
Pin or Drop? A really bad slam...
#1
Posted 2009-February-17, 19:02
Drop Kx onside or pin the 10?
#2
Posted 2009-February-18, 02:55
I'm never very good in percentages, but isn't this a complete guess? We are either playing for Kx and 10xx, or Kxx and 10x. I would think both layouts have the same chance...
*edited* (sorry, missed something, too early, not awake yet)
#3
Posted 2009-February-18, 11:01
#4
Posted 2009-February-18, 11:39
Trumpace, on Feb 18 2009, 12:01 PM, said:
on ♦ LHO plays 3, 4, 7. RHO 2, 5, 9.
on ♣ LHO play 2, 5. RHO J, K.
#5
Posted 2009-February-18, 13:06
mtvesuvius, on Feb 18 2009, 12:39 PM, said:
Trumpace, on Feb 18 2009, 12:01 PM, said:
on ♦ LHO plays 3, 4, 7. RHO 2, 5, 9.
on ♣ LHO play 2, 5. RHO J, K.
I guess I go for the drop then.
#6
Posted 2009-February-18, 13:26
If LHO has Kx they can either duck or put on the K and you are still 'guessing' the next round (since you must play K from K10) even though pretty much anyone worth their salt will hook RHO for the 10.
Looks like a restricted choice situation, right? I pin.
This is how I've always thought about this holding. Maybe I'm wrong.
#7
Posted 2009-February-18, 13:38
I would only trust the signals if they are that newer player type who "just learned signaling" that always signals everything without ever thinking about who wants this info.
#8
Posted 2009-February-18, 13:51
kfay, on Feb 18 2009, 02:26 PM, said:
If LHO has Kx they can either duck or put on the K and you are still 'guessing' the next round (since you must play K from K10) even though pretty much anyone worth their salt will hook RHO for the 10.
Looks like a restricted choice situation, right? I pin.
This is how I've always thought about this holding. Maybe I'm wrong.
...and the moral of the story is duck with Kx...smoothly!?
Call me Desdinova...Eternal Light
C. It's the nexus of the crisis and the origin of storms.
IV: ace 333: pot should be game, idk
e: "Maybe God remembered how cute you were as a carrot."
#10
Posted 2009-February-19, 13:09
Lobowolf, on Feb 18 2009, 02:51 PM, said:
kfay, on Feb 18 2009, 02:26 PM, said:
If LHO has Kx they can either duck or put on the K and you are still 'guessing' the next round (since you must play K from K10) even though pretty much anyone worth their salt will hook RHO for the 10.
Looks like a restricted choice situation, right? I pin.
This is how I've always thought about this holding. Maybe I'm wrong.
...and the moral of the story is duck with Kx...smoothly!?
Yeah I was thinking about this position a lot yesterday after reading the thread.
I think I've finally concluded after some paperwork that if you know the position you should always always always duck from Kx. Covering to 'protect' KT is a red herring.
So theoretically I'm truly at a 50-50 guess if I can pick up the position. However, the position isn't always known and sometimes people will cover the Q from Kx for this very reason. If you can count on a cover some portion of the time then it definitely becomes odds-on to play for the pin. Of course now sometimes you have to figure that they might cover from Kxx for the same reason, but maybe you can assume that this is less frequent.
#11
Posted 2009-February-19, 13:17
kfay, on Feb 19 2009, 11:09 AM, said:
If they cover from Kxx, it's not a problem. The T will pop when you lead from dummy. From KTx, they always have one trick.
#12
Posted 2009-February-19, 13:18
Echognome, on Feb 19 2009, 02:17 PM, said:
kfay, on Feb 19 2009, 11:09 AM, said:
If they cover from Kxx, it's not a problem. The T will pop when you lead from dummy. From KTx, they always have one trick.
lol. duh yeah. i knew this but for some reason it just occured to me to say this at the end my post and i didn't censor myself.
#13
Posted 2009-February-19, 13:31
kfay, on Feb 19 2009, 02:09 PM, said:
If I recall correctly, this is a mixed strategy (or game theory) problem and the answer was to cover with probability 1/3. Perhaps someone can answer for sure.
btw, if you have a count, you don't need all this
It looks like LHO is 2-2-3-6 (yes ♣J and ♣K could be false cards, but if I ruff one club before playing ♠Q... {didn't try to time it out though})
#14
Posted 2009-February-19, 16:27
Quote
No. The answer is defender should never cover. Actually against an optimal declarer anything from cover never to cover 1/3 is equivalent. Everything within this range is the same, as declarer should play for the pin if not covered, and play defender for KT doubleton if there is a cover. So Kx always takes 2 tricks whether you cover or not. Now, if you cover > 1/3, then declarer should switch to running the 9 if covered, losing to KT doubleton but getting it back and then some when you cover.
However, against a non-optimal declarer who thinks you are a bad defender & cover more than you do, and always hooks on the way back, you maximize your gain by never covering.
Of course, the issue is that declarer might not have the QJx depending on the bidding. Letting declarer succeed with the Chinese finesse with Qx might be catastrophic. That complicates matters greatly.
#15
Posted 2009-February-19, 20:34
#16
Posted 2009-February-20, 04:18
wyman, on 2012-May-04, 09:48, said:
rbforster, on 2012-May-20, 21:04, said:
My YouTube Channel
#17
Posted 2009-February-20, 04:50
Left has Kx or Kxx. Right has 10x or 10xx.
No need to think about K10xx or K10x on our left, we lose against that anyway.
With Kxx covering gives away the suit.
With Kx west could have covered to make us believe he holds K10.
So I play for 'best' defense and pin 10.
Finding your own mistakes is more productive than looking for partner's. It improves your game and is good for your soul. (Nige1)
#18
Posted 2009-February-20, 10:22
Stephen Tu, on Feb 19 2009, 05:27 PM, said:
Quote
No. The answer is defender should never cover. Actually against an optimal declarer anything from cover never to cover 1/3 is equivalent. Everything within this range is the same, as declarer should play for the pin if not covered, and play defender for KT doubleton if there is a cover.
Is this true? Is that because stiff K is less likely than KT? I guess that kind of makes sense... I would always hook on the way back though, since you can also cover from Kx.
#19
Posted 2009-February-20, 10:24
#20
Posted 2009-February-20, 10:37
Quote
You can't do anything about stiff K, you always lose a trick to the T eventually even if you hook on the way back. If LHO covers you are only comparing KT doubleton vs. Kx.
Quote
But that depends on how often the opponent is covering from Kx. If he is in fact never covering, you are losing to all the Kx's and KT doubleton. It would be better to at least pick up KT doubleton. If he is covering say half the time (> 1/3), then hooking on the way back will show a profit. Playing for KT doubleton is the unexploitable line. Playing for Kx is exploiting someone who covers too much, but you are losing extra times if you are wrong about them. It probably is the right play against an average unknown opponent though, especially when the QJx is concealed and could be some other holding where covering is a necessity. It's much easier to duck when the QJx is in dummy, although I think weak opps will still tend to cover too much.

Help

On the A♣ lead, LHO plays the 7♣. 2♥ switch and ♥ are 2-2.