barmar, on Sep 18 2009, 07:21 PM, said:
But what constitutes "desirable"? The proponents of these laws claim that it's desirable because God says so.
And what do you mean by "whether it's legal"? Laws define what's legal. I guess you mean constitutional, but the Constitution can be amended. When the religious right discovered that the Constution doesn't prohibit gay marriage, and states were starting to take advantage of this, they started a campaign to amend it. Thankfully, they're not having much luck.
To better state what I meant, I'd say that the ideas, that is the proposed legislation, stands or falls on its own merits. The motivation behind the person who drafted it is incidental.
Desirable is in the eye of the beholder. It doesn't matter why any particular person thinks it's desirable. Ultimately, the question of desirability left to the voters directly, in the case of a ballot initiative, or to the legislators in deciding to pass a bill, or the voters in deciding whether to re-elect the legislators.
The proponents of some laws think that they're desirable because God says so. So what? Each voter decides for himself whether it's desirable or not based on his or her own criteria. Some people think that murder should be illegal on religious reasons, and some people think it should be illegal on purely pragmatic reasons completely divorced from not only religion, but morality. Does it matter?
Yes, by "legal" I meant constitutional; that is, even if a given proposed law is found "desirable," that's not enough if it's unconstitutional (e.g. racially segregated schools were "desirable" in some places prior to Brown vs. Board of Education).
Medical marijuana took a beating in the Raich case, and it came from the "secular left." Property rights took a beating in Kelo, and it came from the "secular left." Is it any better because the motivation is something other than "God says so"? I don't see how.
And living in California (let alone Los Angeles), I'm hard-pressed to believe that it's less common, too. We have a largely-non-religious-right legislature comprised of people who LOVE to impose their beliefs on the rest of us. And it's not just legislators (who sort of have to impose their beliefs on us, as part of their job description); it's the citizenry, too. When gay marriage got CRUSHED in California in 2000, registered Republicans (let alone religious ones) were outnumbered by registered Democrats by something like a million voters. But even on "lesser" issues like whether or not you can talk on a cell phone while you drive, ride a motorcycle without a helmet, let people smoke in the restaurant you own, drive your car without wearing a seat belt, etc. Someone else's belief about what's best for you is imposed on you, and "God says so" has nothing to do with it. If someone thinks God says it's ok to smoke pot in your house, more power to him; I'm in disagreement with the largely secular belief that you're subject to criminal sanctions if you do. The motivations are beside the point.
1. LSAT tutor for rent.
Call me Desdinova...Eternal Light
C. It's the nexus of the crisis and the origin of storms.
IV: ace 333: pot should be game, idk
e: "Maybe God remembered how cute you were as a carrot."