BBO Discussion Forums: Early Knockout versus Late knockout - BBO Discussion Forums

Jump to content

Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

Early Knockout versus Late knockout

#1 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-02, 08:45

I have been reviewing the various matches in the "Unia Winkhaus Leszno" challenge match. The following a large generalization, but the teams that lost in the early rounds generally did so because of poor bidding. To protect the guilty, I will not repeat examples of such bidding. In the last round, however, card playing technique ruled the decision process of who goes on and who goes home.

The biggest culprit leading to defeat was poor defense (probably not a surprize, as defense is harder than offense). Here are a few hands from some of the round four matches where the defense slipped.

In farifie's boys versus roman team, the boys feel on their swords several times.....

97
AT9
8732
Q5432
A83 T5
8632 KQ
5 AK965
AJT87 K9642
KQJ642
J754
QJT
void

Contract 3NT both table, SPADE KING then QUEEN. At the table where boys were on defense, , won by ACE, followed by CLUB ACE at both tables. As you can see there is only 8 tricks. But the boy's South discarded one spade and THREE diamonds on four rounds of clubs (neither declearer took first round club hook need to make the contract). This despite the heart TEN discard by norht showing a heart values. This cost the boys 10 imps.

7
9863
KQ84
AJT7
AK42 Q86
KQ72 AT5
6 973
8543 KQ62
JT953
J4
AJT52
9

EW overbid to 3NT, off the top 6 tricks in the minors. But the defense fell flat. The opening leasd was low Diamond to QUEEN, and diamond 4 back to 9-TEN. Where upon NS destructed and a) failed to continue diamonds, and :o allowed East to wintwo club tricks still without ever leading diamonds again. East came to 2C, and when the heart JACK fell on the second round all of a sudden 9 tricks appeared where once there was only 7. Instead of winning 6 imps, the boys lost another 10, a 16 imp swing.

T6
AK
A87642
KQ2
AKQ82 J93
J5 Q96432
QT53 J9
83 A9
754
T87
K
JT7654

Here the defenders give up a ruff and sluff by playing three rounds of clubs after north bid diamonds, dbled 2S, and south bid 3C before EW settled into 3S. Club to ACE-JACK, club nine to the Queen. trump lead, heart lead. North, on lead now can lead any card in his hand but the club 2 and defeat the contract. He choose the club 2. The only thing I can think is that the defenders got their remaining count signal crossed up. Four clubs easily made at the ohter table (south with 6 clubs and expecting his partner to have 4 for his 2S double, should bid 4C, btw), for a loss of 7 imps. Beating 3S would reduce this to a 2imp lose, gaining 5. So three hands, 31 imps on defense. The boys lost their match by 30 imps.

In the Cauldron versus Just Havn fun match, this defensive jewel was missed.

S-AT9842
H-4
D-KJ93
C-32
Q3 K87
KT7 AQJ53
T874 Q
K875 AQT2
J3
9642
A542
J98
Bidding...
Nor East South West
2S 2N Pass 3N 2N=17-20
Pass Pass Pass

Partner leads the SPADE jack and this dummy appears. Dummy plays low (does not cover)... plan your defense. Imps, neither vul.

This turns out to be a textbook play. Partner's lead of the jack is from shortness. Maybe one, maybe 2. But here is the problem. If declaere has 17 or 18 points, there is not much room in partners hand for anything. He might have an ACE. But your hand would be entryless after a hold up play. The right IMP-based defense is to jump the SPADE ACE and lead the DIAMOND KING, playing partner for the one holdng (and card) that gives you a chance.. Axx of diamonds. The thought being after the king holds, you lead low to the ACE (catching the doubleton Queen) and partner can lead through the D-T8 to your J9. This would work like a charm because declearer held singleton diamond Queen. At the table, north ducked, and declearer ran 10 tricks, for a 1 imp pickup for Havn Fun. The obviously correct defense, would have gained 11 imps (net 10) for us, and we lost by only 5 imps.

Here is a huge swing hand from the Carrot field versus yahoo team. You hold...
S-6532
H-KQ942
D-984
C-5

bidding no one vul
LHO Pard RHO you
Pass Pass 1C Pass
1S 2S 3NT PAss
DBL RDBL All pass

What do you lead? Partner's 2S can't be to play, he is a passed hand, and even so, he would need 6 spades (and no weak 2) and you are lookng at 4S... and LHO bid them. So spade is out. He must be showing a red two suiter (why 2SPADES instead of 2NT) and rho must have running clubs. The obvious lead is a heart, in which case you take the first five tricks. The player with this hand lead a spade, and NS racked up three doubled and redoubled overtricks, for a loss of 14 imps. A heart lead, and you set it one, for a nifty gain of +200 at this table with +420 at the other table, and a gain of 12 imps, for a net swing of 26 imps. This match was decided by 1 imp.

And it wasn't all bad defense. Declearer's slipped occassionally too... here is an example hand that started with an unlucky switch at trick 2 (poor defense) that declearer refused to take advantage of....
J76432
Q632
T
AJ

A
AKT74
J954
732

You LHO Pard RHO
1H 1NT 4H All pass (no alert on 1NT, it was blanced 13 count with no heart stopper but 4-4 in the minors. North with 4-1-4-4 and 7 count took no action suggesting an understanding of the lightness of the 1NT overcall).

Defense.. .requires a trump lead to set the contract. South started DIAMOND ACE and then switched to a trump. Too late now, however, South can scramble to 3D ruffs, 1C, 1S, and 5 hearts... for ten tricks. Starting with a trick three diamond ruff or Spade ACE followed by diamond ruff. But he took spade ACE then lead a club, sealing his won fate, as it allows lho to promote a trump trick for his heart JACK, limiting South to 4 heart winners in his hand.

There is another hand, a 3NT contract, where declearer needs 4 tricks from a spade suit headed by KQJ with a side entry. All he needs do is lead twice towards the KQJ dropping the doubleton ACE on sides. One declearer did and made his contract, one played spade to King then banged the spade QUEEN and went down when suit split 4-2.

Having said that, many of the fourth round matches were very good indeed, with bidding not so much a problem. This should allow the last matches to be based primary on skillful card play. I look foward to the remaining matches.

Ben
--Ben--

#2 User is offline   luis 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 2,143
  • Joined: 2003-May-02
  • Location:Buenos Aires, Argentina

Posted 2003-September-02, 09:20

Excellent report Ben, thanks a lot!
The legend of the black octogon.
0

#3 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-02, 10:32

It is easy to pick one point in the match and say if it had gone the other way that we would have won. What was the result at the other table Ben for the 3N hand in question? Same auction with the same lead and the same duck at trick 1? I think the two crucial parts of the match were our partner's not bidding 5C VUL and the huge hand was the hand where we were in a 80% 24pt slam and our opponents at the other table stopped in 1C. The failure to get to game on this hand is quite egregious. Rather than blaming myself for missing the defense you mentioned, I'll continue to believe we were robbed when J9xx of spades doomed our nice slam.
0

#4 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-02, 11:38

Quote

It is easy to pick one point in the match and say if it had gone the other way that we would have won. What was the result at the other table Ben for the 3N hand in question? Same auction with the same lead and the same duck at trick 1? I think the two crucial parts of the match were our partner's not bidding 5C VUL and the huge hand was the hand where we were in a 80% 24pt slam and our opponents at the other table stopped in 1C. The failure to get to game on this hand is quite egregious. Rather than blaming myself for missing the defense you mentioned, I'll continue to believe we were robbed when J9xx of spades doomed our nice slam.


There was no intent to place blame, I am very sorry if you took it that way. And you are of course right, we were unlucky to play a >75% 6Spade slam down one, when the opponents played the same hand in only 1 club. We were unlucky that the opponents bid a vulnerable 5Clubs at our table while partners, after cue-bidding at the three level, stopped in only 4C. We were unlukcy that our partners took not one but two different lines of play in a cold 3 club contract that then went down. And we were unlucky I didn't start the DIAMOND ACE as I considered on the hand in question. After the 6S down one, I thought they would play that 24 point and in 4S, and the 5 club contract WAS hard to bid, so while we picked up numerous small swings at our table I thought we were significantly behind in the match with two boards to play, and a normal spade lead looks like a normal when we needed a swing. In final analysis I went with the normal lead.

All in our team played excellent bridge, and for a new partnership, I thought we did exceptionally well... in fact exceptionally well for an established partnership. I included this hand as an interesting defensive point. Who knows, although the proposed defense would have worked wonders, maybe my analysis is flawed and best defesne in theory is to duck the spade. Also, when you lose by 5 imps there are plenty of places that could be made up (and the opponents could do things differently too).

As for the result on the 3NT hand in question? Our partners played in their unbreakable 4H contract making an overtrick.

I enjoyed playing on the team with you, and hope to have another oppotunity to do so again in the near future.

Ben
--Ben--

#5 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-02, 11:53

Carrot Field and Farfie's boys self destructed in the round of 4, so it is hard to say how well Roman Team and betonki are playing despite their huge wins.

Cauldron slipped past Just havn fun, surviving two huge bidding mistakes.. playing an 80% 6 spade slam vul in 1 CLUB (lucky for them, JHF bid the slam not the game, and second lucky, this was the 20% of time it went down), and 2, playing 3NT of top five tricks with 4 hearts cold.

Onomatopoeia continues to be very impressive, easily handling the extremely talented misfits team.

Progress played very well against the hopeful winners and eeked out a victory in a tightly contested contest.

Swedish flood had a highly entertaining match with Pomeranian Bridge Union, and haspel squeezed by hola in a highly competitive match.

It is hard to say who is going to win the event, but if I had to place a bet today. my money would be on Onomatopoeia. I had thought that Haspel might be the team to beat, but afer kibitizing both round four matches, it was clear at least this past week that Onomatopoeia was playing the best bridge. But who knows, 16 or 24 boards, anyone can win.

Can someone please post match days and times as they become known.... I would hate to miss these matches...

Ben
--Ben--

#6 User is offline   luis 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 2,143
  • Joined: 2003-May-02
  • Location:Buenos Aires, Argentina

Posted 2003-September-02, 12:07

Well I simulated the conditions and ducking the spade J seems to be the right play, it wins when declarer doesn't have 9 top tricks and pd has an entry usually the club ace or heart ace. Taking the sA is good only when you can cash 4 tricks outside spades and declarer has 9 tricks, and that's very unlikely. Too bad you just run into one of those damned boards.

On the other hand after the 2s preempt it is correct to assume that north has the spade Ace so it may be assumed that south has the other ace when there're two aces left, so declarer's correct play is to cover the sJ, north must take the ace and the defensive communication is broken.
Playing the sQ is also good on the current layout because it is more likely to make the defenders continue spades after playing the sQ from dummy.

Mmmmmm.....
The legend of the black octogon.
0

#7 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-02, 12:17

Quote

Well I simulated the conditions and ducking the spade J seems to be the right play, it wins when declarer doesn't have 9 top tricks and pd has an entry usually the club ace or heart ace. Taking the sA is good only when you can cash 4 tricks outside spades and declarer has 9 tricks, and that's very unlikely. Too bad you just run into one of those damned boards.


But if you duck the spade ACE, so does declearer. Partner continues spades, he has no clue you have such diamond spots, and no matter where partnes trick is (say he has 1 club or 1 heart trick), you are cut off from his hand. And if parntner has a club or heart trick, then the diamond hook is working for 2D, 1S, and certainly 6 tricks in the other two suits after partner takes his trick (say the heart ACE).

If he has the diamond ACE, as was the case, declearer clearly has at 1S and likely 4 hearts and 4 clubs.. and if declearer has a five card club or heart suit even more. But then is one reason I posted this hand, to get feed back. The defense on this hand is certainly not clear, like it was on the other "defensive" error hands shown. And if partner has the diamond queen? Already too late... 1S, 1D, and certainly 7 tricks minimum in clubs and hearts.

Ben
--Ben--

#8 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-02, 14:29

I thoroughly enjoyed our partnership Ben. I was just saying that I think bidding did play
a huge part in our match. I guess there can be four factors: bidding, declarer play, defense and luck. That brings up an interesting point. How would you normalize and evaluate how much each contributed to a win/loss? You could run single-dummy simulations to eliminate the effects of declarer play and defense. The degree to which the actual hands deviated from a random sampling of other potential hands could be a way of measuring luck. This somehow relates to the "goodness" of a certain bid.

I was say our percentages in our loss would be something like: bidding 15%, declarer play 6%, defense 9%, luck 70%. 70% luck just because I can see a 78% slam before I even see your hand and the cards were not kind to us.

Todd
0

#9 User is offline   Erkson 

  • PipPipPipPip
  • Group: Full Members
  • Posts: 258
  • Joined: 2003-May-24

Posted 2003-September-07, 00:37

Quote

I have been reviewing the various matches in the "Unia Winkhaus Leszno" challenge match. The following a large generalization, but the teams that lost in the early rounds generally did so because of poor bidding.
... (cut)....
In the last round, however, card playing technique ruled the decision process of who goes on and who goes home.
....(cut)....
Having said that, many of the fourth round matches were very good indeed, with bidding not so much a problem. This should allow the last matches to be based primary on skillful card play. I look foward to the remaining matches.

Ben


In the two semi-final matches (and especially in the Haspel vs Betonki) didn't bidding play a much bigger role than you thought ?
I counted roughly :
roman_club vs Onomatopoea : skill = 55% bidding = 45%
Haspel vs Betonki : skill = 1% bidding = 99%

Erkson
0

#10 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-07, 08:27

Yes. The big swings in both those matches were related to bidding (or not bidding) games.

Ben
--Ben--

Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

2 User(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 2 guests, 0 anonymous users