1♠ pass 4nt pass
6♠
Page 1 of 1
what is 6 spade
#2
Posted Yesterday, 07:56
Probably means "neither of us know what we are doing".
But if the auction has any sense, 4NT was a natural invite to 6NT and 6S a choice of game between 6NT and 7S.
But if the auction has any sense, 4NT was a natural invite to 6NT and 6S a choice of game between 6NT and 7S.
#3
Posted Yesterday, 07:57
An accept of the quantitative 4NT with a seventh spade (with only six, bid 5♠) perhaps?
Sorry, the 4NT is a terrible bid. Maybe opener panicked and was worried responder would make another strange move?
Sorry, the 4NT is a terrible bid. Maybe opener panicked and was worried responder would make another strange move?
#5
Posted Yesterday, 09:08
Unless you have a very well developed and agreed bidding system that has a prepared (specific) meaning for the 4NT response, the action by responder is impossible. It can mean anything and opener is totally in the dark.
In other words, part of what pescetom & mike777 wrote above.
1. "Neither of us know what we are doing"
2. 6♠ rebid says "I don't care what you meant. I will play here"
In other words, part of what pescetom & mike777 wrote above.
1. "Neither of us know what we are doing"
2. 6♠ rebid says "I don't care what you meant. I will play here"
#6
Posted Yesterday, 09:20
4NT is RKCB for spade, natural invite is too strange for me, and given the wide range, which point count is
sufficient to accept the invite.
6S does not exist, the only explanation I can come up with, would be 2KC+Q and Void, and no willingness of
getting passed in 5S, usually you bid the void (if I recall it correctly), but I may be wrong.
sufficient to accept the invite.
6S does not exist, the only explanation I can come up with, would be 2KC+Q and Void, and no willingness of
getting passed in 5S, usually you bid the void (if I recall it correctly), but I may be wrong.
With kind regards
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)
#7
Posted Yesterday, 15:39
I doubt many good players would use 4 N here as keycard in spades. It’s completely unnecessary. Bid your forcing raise then, if all you need to know is his keycard holding, bid keycard
In my partnerships, this immediate 4N is asking for aces, not interested in the spade king. I think I’ve seen it used once in the last 40 years.
I’d expect a very solid, long suit with a stiff spade and second round controls in the other two suits, such that knowing the number of aces allows responder to place the contract. Say x AKQJ10xxxx KQJ x
1ace, we play the cold 5H. 2, we play the cold 6 H. 3, we play the virtually cold 7N at MPs.
As for 6S…partner does didn’t take 4N as described and he’s on some weird adventure of his own.
In my partnerships, this immediate 4N is asking for aces, not interested in the spade king. I think I’ve seen it used once in the last 40 years.
I’d expect a very solid, long suit with a stiff spade and second round controls in the other two suits, such that knowing the number of aces allows responder to place the contract. Say x AKQJ10xxxx KQJ x
1ace, we play the cold 5H. 2, we play the cold 6 H. 3, we play the virtually cold 7N at MPs.
As for 6S…partner does didn’t take 4N as described and he’s on some weird adventure of his own.
'one of the great markers of the advance of human kindness is the howls you will hear from the Men of God' Johann Hari
#8
Posted Yesterday, 15:59
P_Marlowe, on 2026-November-19, 09:20, said:
4NT is RKCB for spade, natural invite is too strange for me, and given the wide range, which point count is
sufficient to accept the invite.
sufficient to accept the invite.
You would find many like minded partners in my club
The natural invite is already strange, but surely more logical than nuking 3 levels of bidding to ask for keycards knowing only 5 cards and the minimum strength of partner.
Was it so difficult to at least fix trumps?
Our system says that 4NT is plain Blackwood asking for Aces, but the odds that this is the best bid are so small that I try to convince partners to delete it from our card (Italian humour does not extend to "I do not want to play in this partnership any more").
#9
Posted Today, 00:11
Nothing is wrong with fixing trumps.
This assumes, that the partnership has agreed on a way of fixing trumps.
Even if not, I would usually stay low to find out what p has, but I was
not involved at this particular table.
This assumes, that the partnership has agreed on a way of fixing trumps.
Even if not, I would usually stay low to find out what p has, but I was
not involved at this particular table.
With kind regards
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)
Page 1 of 1

Help
