Ingberman/Lebensohl over openers reverse
#1
Posted 2026-November-13, 08:12
Instead, I'd love to hear what you are currently playing (and if you are in an SLTP, please mention that in your reply).
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#3
Posted 2026-November-13, 10:07
#4
Posted 2026-November-13, 11:34
pescetom, on 2026-November-13, 10:07, said:
That's what the heading says
(Surely you didn't think I'd leave out those critical details?)
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#5
Posted 2026-November-13, 11:36
We play that repetition is weak and non forcing with 5 cards whereas 2NT is the French convention Moderateur, weak without 5 cards: with a minimum reverse, Opener will repeat his opening minor giving Responder the chance to pass or raise Opener's second suit. Anything else is game forcing.
My understanding is that Ingberman is similar but Opener with a minimum reverse will always bid 3♣, even if he opened 1♦.
#6
Posted 2026-November-13, 11:53
#7
Posted 2026-November-13, 13:09
DavidKok, on 2026-November-13, 11:53, said:
forcing but can be weak, How do you unravel that?
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#8
Posted 2026-November-13, 13:20
jillybean, on 2026-November-13, 13:09, said:
With a min reverse, opener can bid 2NT, 3 of their suit, or sometimes bid 3 of responder s major with 5422 and no stopper. With a 3-cd fit, you usually want to play game in resp suit (so you bid it with a min reverse and splinter with a max, everyone knows the shortage but you can help responder to go to slam if not min).
#9
Posted 2026-November-13, 15:19
I play inbermam, although in a lot of situations it is the same as lebensohl.
As for auctions such as 1D 1S 2 H 2S, it’s far more efficient o play this as 5+ with no strength implications (fixed a typo)than to play it as weak. Just go through the various permutations and it should be obvious.
As for how you untangle it, opener makes a natural rebid which is descriptive but non forcing and responder does whatever looks best to him. The exception would be a monster hand for opener with 3 card spade support. Now he won’t usually risk 3S over 2S. He’ll bid 4S (on most hands).
I’ve discussed this with some decent flight B players who used the major rebid as weak. I gave them a few example hands where responder had gf values opposite a reverse and they simply got lost after having to manufacture a bid because they feared opener passing 2M.
#10
Posted 2026-November-13, 15:39
mikeh, on 2026-November-13, 15:19, said:
I play inbermam, although in a lot of situations it is the same as lebensohl.
As for auctions such as 1D 1S 2 H 2S, it’s far more efficient o play this as 5+ with no strength imo,icatiins than to play it as weak. Just go through the various permutations and it should be obvious.
As for how you untangle it, opener makes a natural rebid which is descriptive but non forcing and responder does whatever looks best to him. The exception would be a monster hand for opener with 3 card spade support. Now he won’t usually risk 3S over 2S. He’ll bid 4S (on most hands).
I’ve discussed this with some decent flight B players who used the major rebid as weak. I gave them a few example hands where responder had gf values opposite a reverse and they simply got lost after having to manufacture a bid because they feared opener passing 2M.
I have no idea about either SLPT or icatiins (but ica**i in Italian is pretty clear
I am probably equivalent to an ACBL flight B player and I use the major rebid as weak (although as I said many here play it forcing and I could live with that too).
IIUC you are asking what happens with GF values and spades in the auction where 2S is weak NF:
1D - 1S
2H - ?
With 6 spades I would bid 3S (GF) and with 5 spades I would bid 2NT then 3S (now GF).
#11
Posted 2026-November-13, 16:54
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#12
Posted 2026-November-13, 16:54
pescetom, on 2026-November-13, 15:39, said:
I am probably equivalent to an ACBL flight B player and I use the major rebid as weak (although as I said many here play it forcing and I could live with that too).
IIUC you are asking what happens with GF values and spades in the auction where 2S is weak NF:
1D - 1S
2H - ?
With 6 spades I would bid 3S (GF) and with 5 spades I would bid 2NT then 3S (now GF).
I also learned the rebid of the major as weak. Root-Pavlicek, "Structured Reverses." I find it works fine.Decades old.
Gf with 5 of the major goes thru fourth suit. Not 2NT, which is always artificial and weak.Again this is old stuff but it works, I know it, most importantly.
However this is definitely not expert standard in ACBL. Expert standard is as DavidK and MikeH described it.
I thought I was the only one who had no idea what SLPT was
#13
Posted 2026-November-13, 16:56
pescetom, on 2026-November-13, 15:39, said:
I am probably equivalent to an ACBL flight B player and I use the major rebid as weak (although as I said many here play it forcing and I could live with that too).
IIUC you are asking what happens with GF values and spades in the auction where 2S is weak NF:
1D - 1S
2H - ?
With 6 spades I would bid 3S (GF) and with 5 spades I would bid 2NT then 3S (now GF).
2NT is a relay to 3♣ and now 3♠ is GF?
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#15
Posted 2026-November-14, 03:36
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#16
Posted 2026-November-14, 05:58
2 of our suit is natural, weak and non-forcing.
2NT, 3♣, 3♦, 3♥ are transfers to suit above (if that is one of our 3 suits). Opener bidding anything except completing the transfer is GF.
Cheaper of 2 in the 4th suit and a transfer to the 4th suit is GF and shows exactly 5 cards in our (major) suit. This essentially replaces most of the GF hands that rebid the suit in Standard.
The more expensive of these 2 calls shows a 6 card suit and denies a good stopper in the 4th suit. This is only available if Opener's suits are clubs and diamonds.
3♠ is a stopper ask in the 4th suit.
3NT is to play.
=====
1♣ - 1♥; 2♦
==
2♥ = to play
2♠ = exactly 5 hearts, gf
2NT = to play 3♣, or GF with clubs
3♣ = to play 3♦, or GF with diamonds
3♦ = GF with hearts
3♥ = 6+ hearts and no good spade stop, GF
3♠ = stopper ask
3NT = to play
=====
1♣ - 1♠; 2♦
==
2♥ = exactly 5 spades, GF
2♠ = to play
2NT = to play 3♣, or GF with clubs
3♣ = to play 3♦, or GF with diamonds
3♦ = 6+ spades and no good heart stop, GF
3♥ = GF with spades
3♠ = stopper ask
3NT = to play
=====
1♣ - 1♠; 2♥
==
2♠ = to play
2NT = to play 3♣, or GF with clubs
3♣ = exactly 5 spades, gf
3♦ = to play 3♥, or GF with hearts
3♥ = GF with spades
3♠ = stopper ask
3NT = to play
=====
1♦ - 1♠; 2♥
==
2♠ = to play
2NT = exactly 5 spades, gf
3♣ = to play 3♦, or GF with diamonds
3♦ = to play 3♥, or GF with hearts
3♥ = GF with spades
3♠ = stopper ask
3NT = to play
=====
#17
Posted 2026-November-14, 07:11
pescetom, on 2026-November-13, 18:08, said:
awm, on 2026-November-14, 03:36, said:
1♦:1♠
2♥:2N
3♦.
Natural bidding
I wonder why the NA version forces 3♣
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#18
Posted 2026-November-14, 11:42
jillybean, on 2026-November-14, 07:11, said:
2♥:2N
3♦.
Natural bidding
I wonder why the NA version forces 3♣
I suspect that Ingberman had a mechanistic mentality (he is sometimes credited with inventing splinters).
Our system designer was careful to select/design conventions as close as possible to natural bidding, it makes them more intuitive and easier for intermediates to remember. So in this case he chose the French version that uses the natural rebid rather than a Puppet.
Unfortunately in this case I ruined things by tagging onto the cheapest reverse my Multirever to handle strong minor hands, which uses an almost opposite logic. Of course partner will wake us up with an alert
#19
Posted 2026-November-14, 13:01
jillybean, on 2026-November-14, 07:11, said:
2♥:2N
3♦.
Natural bidding
I wonder why the NA version forces 3♣
It doesn’t force 3C. It’s often written as if it does but, imo, that’s misleading. Opener will rebid 3C most of the time, but not all of the time. Say you open 1D with 3=4=6=0and, over a 1S response, you reverse into 2H. Now partner bids 2N. Do not bid 3C!
Why? Because if he has 4=2=1=6 he will pass 3C. Ok, if his clubs are KQJ10xx and no other hcp, 3C will be the best spot but he doesn’t exactly promise that
So my rule is that opener will bid 3C unless he really can’t stand declaring 3C. Btw, 5=6 reds usually wnt bid 3C either, choosing 3H to show shape.
#20
Posted 2026-November-14, 15:39
mikeh, on 2026-November-14, 13:01, said:
Why? Because if he has 4=2=1=6 he will pass 3C. Ok, if his clubs are KQJ10xx and no other hcp, 3C will be the best spot but he doesn’t exactly promise that
So my rule is that opener will bid 3C unless he really can’t stand declaring 3C. Btw, 5=6 reds usually wnt bid 3C either, choosing 3H to show shape.
I wouldn't be surprised if Ingberman was smart enough to think like you.
But the majority of internet sources still available in dumbed-down google including Simon's Conventions, Bridge-Tips, BridgeWebs, bridgebum and of course AI like Gemini all say that one must puppet to 3♣.
The only dissenting article is by a certain Mike H. and on an unpopular WBF Junior site.
Such is and is so determined "fact" in 2026, good luck to future generations.

Help
