Page 1 of 1
Transfer advances of takeout doubles ? Info, pls :-)
#1
Posted 2005-March-22, 05:48
Hi all, I'd be very interested inthe development of transfer advances to t/o doubles.
I already had a look at Misho+Ben's Equality", but I found only development to 1m-X-p, when bidding room is not a problem.
Instead, I am especially interested in the auction starting:
1S-X-p- ?
If using xfer advances:
1. do you use 1NT as xfer to 2C (giving up the often safe 1NT spot) ?
2. do you use 1NT as natural (giving up the natural, safe 2C response when u have long clubs) ?
3. what suit do you transfer to if you are 4432 with 3 cards in H and 2 in S (opps opened 1S) and no stoppers ?
....3.1 = with a weak hand
....3.2 = with constructive hand
....3.3 = with invitational hand
....3.4 = with GF hand
Any suggestions, links and references are greatly appreciated !!
Thanks !
Mauro
I already had a look at Misho+Ben's Equality", but I found only development to 1m-X-p, when bidding room is not a problem.
Instead, I am especially interested in the auction starting:
1S-X-p- ?
If using xfer advances:
1. do you use 1NT as xfer to 2C (giving up the often safe 1NT spot) ?
2. do you use 1NT as natural (giving up the natural, safe 2C response when u have long clubs) ?
3. what suit do you transfer to if you are 4432 with 3 cards in H and 2 in S (opps opened 1S) and no stoppers ?
....3.1 = with a weak hand
....3.2 = with constructive hand
....3.3 = with invitational hand
....3.4 = with GF hand
Any suggestions, links and references are greatly appreciated !!
Thanks !
Mauro
"Bridge is like dance: technique's important but what really matters is not to step on partner's feet !"
#2
Posted 2005-March-22, 05:54
I think you're going to get into trouble if you skip the natural 1NT bid. Note that there is a difference between
1S X 1NT
and
1S X pass 1NT
In the 1st case you can do away with the natural 1NT (the situation is not forcing), but in the second it's much riskier (you'll be stuck for a bid on 4333 and 7-10 points).
Misho/Ben's scheme always retains a natural 1NT because of this problem. Also in the 1st case, eventhough the situation is not so critical.
1S X 1NT
and
1S X pass 1NT
In the 1st case you can do away with the natural 1NT (the situation is not forcing), but in the second it's much riskier (you'll be stuck for a bid on 4333 and 7-10 points).
Misho/Ben's scheme always retains a natural 1NT because of this problem. Also in the 1st case, eventhough the situation is not so critical.
#3
Posted 2005-March-22, 05:56
whereagles, on Mar 22 2005, 11:54 AM, said:
I think you're going to get into trouble if you skip the natural 1NT bid.
Yes, that was my feeling...
So I'd like to get access to a complete coverage of xfer response schemes to t/o double.
"Bridge is like dance: technique's important but what really matters is not to step on partner's feet !"
#4
Posted 2005-March-22, 06:10
It should be fairly easy to implement transfer advances in this situation. The only point is whether you're going to keep 2NT as natural or not.
For instance, if you keep 2NT as nat..
1S dbl pass ..?
1N = nat 7-10, eventually 6 if stuck
2x = nat 0-7
2S = clubs 8+. Since pard is going to bid 2NT or 3C most of the time, you can also put more stuff here, à lá equality
2N = nat 11-12, 1 stopper
3C = diams
3D = hearts
3H = some wierd two-suiter
3S = ask for stop and/or some wierd one or two-suiter
3N = nat 13-15
etc... probably Ben has better ideas on this, though.
For instance, if you keep 2NT as nat..
1S dbl pass ..?
1N = nat 7-10, eventually 6 if stuck
2x = nat 0-7
2S = clubs 8+. Since pard is going to bid 2NT or 3C most of the time, you can also put more stuff here, à lá equality
2N = nat 11-12, 1 stopper
3C = diams
3D = hearts
3H = some wierd two-suiter
3S = ask for stop and/or some wierd one or two-suiter
3N = nat 13-15
etc... probably Ben has better ideas on this, though.
#5
Posted 2005-March-22, 07:23
whereagles, on Mar 22 2005, 12:10 PM, said:
It should be fairly easy to implement transfer advances in this situation. The only point is whether you're going to keep 2NT as natural or not.
For instance, if you keep 2NT as nat..
1S dbl pass ..?
......
For instance, if you keep 2NT as nat..
1S dbl pass ..?
......
Ty Nuno, so in the method you suggest, how do you respond to 1S-X-p-? in the following 4 cases?
you are 4432 with 3 cards in H and 2 in S (opps opened 1S) and no stoppers ?
....3.1 = with a weak hand (0-7)
....3.2 = with constructive hand (8-10-)
....3.3 = with invitational hand (10+/bad12)
....3.4 = with GF hand
according to your method, I can bid 3S for the GF hand, but I have trouble identifying the best sequences for weak, constructive and invitational hand.
"Bridge is like dance: technique's important but what really matters is not to step on partner's feet !"
#6
Posted 2005-March-22, 08:08
Hum.. let's see. If you don't dump anything into 2S and keep that as clubs only, you'd have, for the 4432...
1. Weak: bid 2H
2,3,4. Constructive & others: bid 3D
In case 2,3,4 if pard takes the transfer to 3H, he's probably around 11-14. In this zone he'll normally have 4 hearts. Now I pass with 8-11 and might take a shot at game with 12 (or a good 11). With the GF hand I can bid 3S after the transfer (shows 4 hearts) or 3NT (5 hearts). Better use 3S as 4 cards so as not to wrong-side 3NT if pard only has 3 hearts. If pard has more than 11-14, he will skip the transfer and cue (3 hearts) or bid 3NT (no heart support, likely a stopper). This also works well in conjunction with Raptor 1NT: with 15-17 you just skip the transfer and that's it.
Now, if you mobilize 2S into clubs OR hearts 8-10, you'll have an easier time. With 8-10 just bid 2S. Pard will bid 3C with 11-14, after which you bid 3H. With the 15-17 hand he bids 2NT and you can follow up with 3S. Better do this in 3S because 3H would be clubs + hearts, strongish. If you have hearts and 11+, just transfer. Pard will know you'll have 11+ or compensating distribution (say 8-10 with 5 cards).
Again, there's a lot of scope for improvement here. I just gave you one possibility.
1. Weak: bid 2H
2,3,4. Constructive & others: bid 3D
In case 2,3,4 if pard takes the transfer to 3H, he's probably around 11-14. In this zone he'll normally have 4 hearts. Now I pass with 8-11 and might take a shot at game with 12 (or a good 11). With the GF hand I can bid 3S after the transfer (shows 4 hearts) or 3NT (5 hearts). Better use 3S as 4 cards so as not to wrong-side 3NT if pard only has 3 hearts. If pard has more than 11-14, he will skip the transfer and cue (3 hearts) or bid 3NT (no heart support, likely a stopper). This also works well in conjunction with Raptor 1NT: with 15-17 you just skip the transfer and that's it.
Now, if you mobilize 2S into clubs OR hearts 8-10, you'll have an easier time. With 8-10 just bid 2S. Pard will bid 3C with 11-14, after which you bid 3H. With the 15-17 hand he bids 2NT and you can follow up with 3S. Better do this in 3S because 3H would be clubs + hearts, strongish. If you have hearts and 11+, just transfer. Pard will know you'll have 11+ or compensating distribution (say 8-10 with 5 cards).
Again, there's a lot of scope for improvement here. I just gave you one possibility.
#7
Posted 2005-March-22, 08:17
Chamaco, on Mar 22 2005, 09:23 AM, said:
....3.1 = with a weak hand (0-7)
....3.2 = with constructive hand (8-10-)
....3.3 = with invitational hand (10+/bad12)
....3.4 = with GF hand
according to your method, I can bid 3S for the GF hand, but I have trouble identifying the best sequences for weak, constructive and invitational hand.
....3.2 = with constructive hand (8-10-)
....3.3 = with invitational hand (10+/bad12)
....3.4 = with GF hand
according to your method, I can bid 3S for the GF hand, but I have trouble identifying the best sequences for weak, constructive and invitational hand.
(1S)-DBL-PASS-? ? ?
First, realize that 1S-x shows a higher minimum than 1C-x. If it doesn't either you takeout doubles of 1C require too much stregnth or your takeout doubles of 1S can be made too lightly. This "extra" should be in terms of hcp or distribution.
3.1 With a weak hand (0-7)
Bid cheapest biddable suit. Ok, ok... I know parnter wants you to bid hearts if you have them. And with 5, 6, 7 or four with all points in hearts, I gladly bid hearts. But sometimes, when really broke, I will bid a minor here. The point is, when you bid hearts, your partner with some extra values will often raise getting you too high. Results show bidding the minor discourage partner, but also gets you in the anti-field contract. So it is up to you... but clearly bid inexpensively
3.2 = with constructive hand (8-10-)
Ok, I would define constructive differently....but lets see. First, unless you are planning on bidding NT, discount Q or J in spades. Add a point for a fourth heart (fit), and two points for a fifth HEART, and three points for ANY six card suit. With 9-11 points (including these bonus points), do one of two things. This means some 10 point hand (with Queen in their suit) are bid cheaply, some seven point hands are pushed (with five card heart suit). 1) Jump in five or six card suit, 2) jump even in four card heart suit, 3) bid 1NT (with good 7 to bad 11). Bid 2 of a minor with four cards there.
I got these ranges, if I remeber correctly, from Eddie Kantar. But I don't use them quite like this in response to a minor suit suit takeout double, but do use them in the response to a major suit takeout double...where the lenght issue is more valuable because partner either has more shape or more hcp at a minimum...
3.3 = with initational hand (12+ including bonus points for legnth)
Jump to 2NT, cue-bid, jump to game (if more than invite)
The cue-bid is not game force, but nearly so. You may want to consider this auction...
(1♠) DBL (PASS) 2S
(Pass) 2NT
What does 2NT mean? Big hand? I don't really have hearts? After a cue-bid, any natural NT rebid hand is enough to force to game, with a jump to 3NT. So I play this as doubler's attempt to get out cheaply. That is a new suit by I use this as original takeout doubler's warning that he doubled light and the auction can die in 3 of a suit. Advancer must not bid 3 of a suit here unless he is willing to play there (minimum cue-bid). This makes all new suits by opener over the cue-bid forcing.
--Ben--
#9
Posted 2005-March-22, 08:45
whereagles, on Mar 22 2005, 10:27 AM, said:
Ben.. don't you play transfer advances after takeout dbl of 1S??
Case one...
(1S)=DBL=My bid (where my partner opened 1S), I do play transfer advance
Case two
(1S)-DBL-Pass-my bid (where my parnter doubled and next hand passed), I do not play transfer advances
Case three
(1S)-DBL-(bid)-my bid (where my partner doubled, and next hand bid), I do play a bastardized version of transfer advance
Case four
(1C)-1H-(pass)-my bid (where partner overcalled and next hand passed), I play a hybrid transfer advance... 1S/1NT is natural, 2C is transfer to D, 2D is "constructive heart raise", 2H is less than constructive raise. Others normal.
Ben
--Ben--
#11
Posted 2005-March-23, 10:15
I haven't heard of [1x] - dbl - [pass] - 1y as being a transfer.
I like having the opening bidder on lead, so this idea doesn't seem sound to me.
I like having the opening bidder on lead, so this idea doesn't seem sound to me.
"Phil" on BBO
Page 1 of 1

Help
