Thanks to Fred and BBO yellows for great job !!!
Directors in BBO tournaments are volunteers and may be havent experience as directors in live tournaments. I have it and have national status as director. I think that online bridge have great advantage was playing by computers. This make possible to decide easy because all can be recorded. Most of often mistakes at table, like bid out of order, wrong card played .... cannot happen. Some of calls of director like "not alerted", "slow play" ... can be simple marked during play without calling director. Ofcourse players must have same choice by BBO software. This will up pleasure playing in BBO tournamets ( prevent talking "hot" words at table ) and speed up tourney with less director calls. After tourney finish, such "late calls" can be judged. Results will be publish after score adjust.
Convention cards must be obligatory for pairs not play SAYC or 2/1 or rare conventions. They must be publish at least 1 hour before tournament begin. For regular pairs it must be publish in some kind of tournament database.
Misho
Page 1 of 1
Directors
#2
Posted 2003-May-27, 15:16
In my opinion this is quite a good idea, but it's not so important. It would be of course fair to do such thing, but i don't think directors would have time and would feel like judging a few dozens of boards (cause I think there are lots of complains and there'd be much more if such posibility existed) after the tourney. It's a lot of work and we shouldn't forget that those tourneys are mainly for fun - the results are not that important (for me it's enough to know myself i played well).
#3
Posted 2003-May-28, 05:25
Something to remember - the more serious of a tourney desired the more work it takes the TD's. Instituting a policy like this would require vigilant enforcement. Last I checked posting CC's at most clubs isn't required and in fact are only looked at if there's a question.
Another issue is many tourneys are played with pickup partners who may only discuss and agree upon the basics of their systems. I have no desire to alienate these individuals.
Something a lot of people seem to forget when clamoring to the directors about misalerted calls is that damage has to be done, such as a misalerted bid caused a player to bid/not bid in a situation or alter their card play. Most of the cases I've come upon neither has seriously been affected.
Soon we will be able to hand-edit scores but it's going to be a case by case thing and odds are if it wouldn't otherwise include a procedural penalty it would be a lower priority. In our tournaments if someone needs to be repeatedly assessed procedural penalties it's just more prudent to bar their participation in future tourneys.
Take care,
John
Another issue is many tourneys are played with pickup partners who may only discuss and agree upon the basics of their systems. I have no desire to alienate these individuals.
Something a lot of people seem to forget when clamoring to the directors about misalerted calls is that damage has to be done, such as a misalerted bid caused a player to bid/not bid in a situation or alter their card play. Most of the cases I've come upon neither has seriously been affected.
Soon we will be able to hand-edit scores but it's going to be a case by case thing and odds are if it wouldn't otherwise include a procedural penalty it would be a lower priority. In our tournaments if someone needs to be repeatedly assessed procedural penalties it's just more prudent to bar their participation in future tourneys.
Take care,
John
John Chodan (skrshawk)
Administrator, BridgeBase Forums
Administrator, BridgeBase Forums
Page 1 of 1

Help
