your bid
#21
Posted 2010-March-10, 07:38
#22
Posted 2010-March-10, 10:48
Echognome, on Mar 9 2010, 09:18 PM, said:
jdonn, on Mar 9 2010, 09:01 AM, said:
Your bid on xx AQxx AQJTx xx after 1♦ - 1♠?
But fine 2=4=6=1 would have been better to the point. Or do you think that's not possible either?
I think you know what I would rebid on the first hand. And I hope the second part was sarcastic hehe.
#23
Posted 2010-March-10, 17:29
#24
Posted 2010-March-11, 02:30
Fluffy, on Mar 10 2010, 07:24 AM, said:
If partner raises 2♥ to 3♥ your bid is 3NT, yes, you might lack a club stopper, but after a major has been raised and its not gonna be a good spot your only way to show it is to bid 3NT ASAP. You don't know if 3NT is good or not, but you do know 4♥ is silly.
Your bid is 3NT? Many play this as a serious, (or frivolous), slam try. That is why I disagree with 2H. Why not play 2NT as an artifical waiting bid? This is common in Polish Club systems and avoids silly bids like 2h on a 3 card suit.
Sure you lose a natural 2NT, however as partner has already shown 6Ds this is not much of a loss. As I have stated in previous posts, you are unlikely to make 8 tricks - if the Ds come in, you will probably make more; if not ...well....
#25
Posted 2010-March-14, 12:08
The only additional part you need to agree on is that opener's raise to 3H is forcing. If you have an invitational hand with 5-4 in the majors opposite an opening bid with e.g. a 1=4=5=3 then you will end in game when 3H might have been better, but that is not the end of the world.
So after 1D - 1S; 2D - 2H; 3H - ? responder bids 3NT to say he didn't have four hearts after all but was looking for the best game; he bids 4D to show a slam try in diamonds; he bids 4C to agree hearts and make a slam try. Whether 3S agrees hearts or is natural and forcing depends if you had a forcing way to bid spades earlier in the auction (e.g. by a strong jump shift).
Quote
Including slam in hearts...
xx
AQ109
Axxxxx
A
#26
Posted 2010-March-15, 09:08
#27
Posted 2010-March-15, 12:08
jillybean, on Mar 8 2010, 01:49 PM, said:
uncontested auction
3C
I need to force to game somehow and 3nt is too committal
not pretty.
#28
Posted 2010-March-17, 18:44
FrancesHinden, on Mar 14 2010, 11:08 AM, said:
Frances, I don't understand why 3H must be forcing. After 1D:1S 2D:2H opener has already limited the hand, why can't we stop in 3H?
Thanks.
Bridge should be fun!
SHAPE!
"And no matter what methods you play, it is essential, for anyone aspiring to learn to be a good player, to learn the importance of bidding shape properly." (MH)
#29
Posted 2010-March-19, 16:43
The problem comes when opener has a maximum for his 2D bid (and/or a hand that has improved opposite hearts) and wants to accept responder's invitation and bid game. If you just jump to 4H, which you would do if 2H promised a 4-card suit, then you have made the auction very difficult if, say, the hands are
AQJxx
KJx
Kx
Jxx
Kx
Axxx
AQ10xxx
x
(you want to play in 6D or 6S)
or
AQJxx
KJx
Kx
Jxx
x
Qxxx
AQJ10x
A10x
(3NT is the spot, and personally I would not have rebid 1NT on the South cards)
Now you could instead agree to play, say, 3C as just generically forcing over the 2H bid including 4-card heart support, but that really starts to make the auction very messy indeed, because you also want to use 3C as a general fourth-suit bid on a maximum hand that doesn't have four hearts but doesn't know what the strain ought to be.

Help

1♦ : 1♠
2♦ : ?