MP's, mixed pairs Would you have done better?
#1
Posted 2009-September-15, 07:09
So, I was trying to play 5-card Majors with weak no-trump and I think I blew two hands in bidding:
♠Jxx
♥KQ
♦AT
♣KQT8xx
I opened 1♣, got 1♥ from partner and should have rebid???
Later I held:
♠Kxx
♥Txx
♦Qx
♣QJ7xx
Partner opened 1NT (12-14) and RHO bid 2♥ natural, what's your action?
Another I couldn't handle properly:
♠KTxxx
♥KTxx
♦Qx
♣9x
Bidding goes:
1♣ 1♠ Pa Pa
3♣ Pa ???
wyman, on 2012-May-04, 09:48, said:
rbforster, on 2012-May-20, 21:04, said:
My YouTube Channel
#2
Posted 2009-September-15, 08:49
2) You did not provide vulnerability. My philosophy playing weak NTs is to get into and out of the auction as quickly as possible. My partner's 1NT opening put my RHO in a situation which few other pairs will face. There is no guarantee that RHO's 2♥ call will be good for their side, especially since I know for a fact that our side has at least 5, and possibly more, hearts. You could compete in clubs (using Lebensohl or any other method that you have) but I suggest passing in the hope that they have made a mistake. Competing could turn a plus (or a small minus) into a large minus.
3) 3NT seems clear.
#3
Posted 2009-September-15, 09:11
2) I would compete at any vulnerability.
3) Gotta agree with Art here, 3NT seems clear.
#4
Posted 2009-September-15, 09:22
2. I pass, wrong shape for competion.
3. There is no third problem. Or did you want to double partner to show your majors?
Roland
Sanity Check: Failure (Fluffy)
More system is not the answer...
#5
Posted 2009-September-15, 09:39
2) I pass because nothing else fits. Nothing is wrong in getting a plus score defending, right? We have a balanced hand and full of queens. I say let's defend.
3) I would have made a negative double the previous round because I was not prepared to penalty pass 1♠X. But now I bid 3NT.
We are all connected to each other biologically, to the Earth chemically, and to the rest of the universe atomically.
We're in the universe, and the universe is in us.
#6
Posted 2009-September-15, 10:24
#7
Posted 2009-September-15, 10:54
-gwnn
#8
Posted 2009-September-15, 11:24
2) since it is MP I would try a nonforcing 3♣
3)3NT
the Freman, Chani from the move "Dune"
"I learned long ago, never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it."
George Bernard Shaw
#10
Posted 2009-September-15, 12:15
B) Pass, assuming we are playing takeout doubles. Ok, maybe at w/w i would compete to 3♣.
c) 3N.
#11
Posted 2009-September-15, 12:43
maggieb, on Sep 15 2009, 10:11 AM, said:
LOL
#12
Posted 2009-September-15, 13:05
The first 1 is 1NT, for the many reasons maggie suggester plus: it is mixed pairs!. And also because it might let you play in hearts if partner has 5 wich might sore 140 against 130.
#13
Posted 2009-September-15, 14:40
2. Pass. Partner will usually reopen with a doubleton heart and, if not, you are better off passing. If you do play 3♣, either they lead through partner's heart holding or your mixed pairs partner is declarer.
3. 3NT. Partner's failure to reopen with a double means that 3♣ may be distributional rather than having a lot of high cards, but still passing is too pessimistic with this hand.
#14
Posted 2009-September-15, 15:13
Quote
Around here, men should sit North or West (screens!) and women can sit wherever they want. That's emancipation for you...
Quote
I would bid 1NT all the time. You are between 2♣ and 3♣ and besides, perhaps 2♥ is the spot.
Quote
I pass, don't see any good action, 20 HCP doesn't mean we have to be active all the time.
Quote
I'm going to bid 3NT now but would have been happier if I had bid 1 round earlier.
#15
Posted 2009-September-15, 16:14
2. Penalty double if, like me, you play it (assuming MP), and pass if not.
3. 3nt.
#17
Posted 2009-September-17, 06:39
♠Jxx
♥KQ
♦AT
♣KQT8xx
I just bid 2♣. I think this is one of the bids you do with the hope of surviving (i.e. partner won't pass) so that you can describe your hand better. 1NT or 3♣ would have also been good, my REALLY bad bid came afterwards when I responded 2♥ to 2♦ and passed partner's 4♥. She held:
♠AKQx
♥ATxxx
♦Qxxx
♣Void
And 6 was made for a good score via a squeeze (hearts behaved, ♣AJxxx and ♦Kxx were in opening leader's hand)
I lebensohled on the second hand:
♠Kxx
♥Txx
♦Qx
♣QJ7xx
For -200 when my partner had a not so fitting hand for the 3 level (she opened on 11). I'm still not sure it was a bad bid, though.
On the final hand:
♠KTxxx
♥KTxx
♦Qx
♣9x
I bid 3NT and went four down when South led from ♦AJxxxxx to her partner's ♦Kx. My partner held:
♠J
♥Axx
♦Tx
♣AKQJxxx
And I now think I should have doubled 1♠ looking for the heart fit. Maybe we would have gotten to the same contract, but still, my hand wasn't that good for penalizing 1♠.
On to the second round.
wyman, on 2012-May-04, 09:48, said:
rbforster, on 2012-May-20, 21:04, said:
My YouTube Channel
#18
Posted 2009-September-17, 07:41
2. would probably compete w/w, definately not red
3. 3NT
Having seen what partner had, why on earth would i want to be in 6♥ on #1? Think I'd be with much of the field in 3N.
On the third one clearly you've been unlucky, but doubling 1♠ would have been awful. Personally I'd have tried 1NT at your first turn which would have fetched 3NT from pard for the same result, shouldn't think you were alone in 3NT-4.
#19
Posted 2009-September-17, 10:00
Hanoi5, on Sep 17 2009, 02:39 PM, said:
♠Kxx
♥Txx
♦Qx
♣QJ7xx
For -200 when my partner had a not so fitting hand for the 3 level (she opened on 11). I'm still not sure it was a bad bid, though.
Down 4 was unlucky and certainly 1 or 2 more down than what you'll normally be.
#20
Posted 2009-September-17, 11:23
MFA, on Sep 17 2009, 11:00 AM, said:
Hanoi5, on Sep 17 2009, 02:39 PM, said:
♠Kxx
♥Txx
♦Qx
♣QJ7xx
For -200 when my partner had a not so fitting hand for the 3 level (she opened on 11). I'm still not sure it was a bad bid, though.
Down 4 was unlucky and certainly 1 or 2 more down than what you'll normally be.
Any reason you are assuming he is NV other than that it is absolutely insane to bid vul (I guess some people play weak NT only NV also)?
Bidding is awful, you have a totally defensive hand with THREE hearts (worst number ever). They are more likely than not to be in a 7 card fit. Even if they aren't, if you have 8 clubs and they have 8 hearts it will often be right to pass.
Sure if you have 9 clubs and they have 8 hearts it is right to bid, but that gives partner x2x4 and he is likely to reopen with a double with that shape anyways. And when hes 4243 he might reopen with a double anyways. And when he has 5 spades he might reopen with 2S which will be better than 3C.

Help
