kgr, on Sep 16 2009, 01:05 AM, said:
But I'm also interested in the probabilities for best play without taking into account the info you got from the bidding and without taking into account the psycholgies of the plays.
(I wonder how difficult that question is).
Probabilities can be very easy if you ignore information, but that gives you a false number. If you really want to become a good bridge player, you must assign conditional probabilities based on previous information. For example, my estimate was that if East held the HK and 6+ hearts, he had a near 0% probability of holding the CQ -- although the mathematics would say that he had a significant, non-zero chance.
Anyway, if you want the misleading math, use
http://www.automaton.../en/OddsTbl.htm for odds given vacant spaces:
Line 1 depends on how you play after each heart break. I already said that I do not think East can have the CQ if he holds a 6+ heart suit with the king, but pure math would ignore that. The odds of each heart break in isolation with 5 empty spaces to 10 are roughly:
1-7 : 9%
2-6 : 34%
3-5 : 40%
4-4 : 17%
If you always play the long club hand for the queen, then my back-of-the-envelope calculation is :
9% * 4/7 (hearts are 1-7, clubs are 4-3, and heart king cannot be singleton) +
6/8 * 34% * 4/7 (hearts are 2-6, clubs are 3-4) + 2/8 * 34% (doubleton HK) +
40% * 5/7 (hearts are 3-5, clubs are 2-5) +
17% * 7/7 (hearts are 4-4, clubs are 1-6, and we always find the CQ)
(4.5%) + (14% + 8.5%) + (28%) + (17%) = 73%.
Line 2 is strictly P(doubleton CQ or restricted choice finesse) = 2/7 * P(2-5 or 5-2 break given the 8-3 ratio) + 67% - P(both) = 11% + 67% - (67%)(11%) = 11% + 67% - 8% = 70%.
So surprisingly, the pure math slightly supports line 1. I hadn't expected that because a restricted choice finesse is usually quite strong (2/3).
At the table I would know none of the probabilities based on vacant spaces -- I would just follow the reasoning I outlined in my first reply. Even if I had all the odds memorized, I wouldn't do it because the numbers I get from the calculation are misleading. Garbage in, garbage out.
5D-(Pass)-6D-All Pass