Posted 2009-September-13, 14:12
The two auctions are somewhat different.
In the old thread, the doubler's first chance to act was at the four level. He might double on a nice-looking 13-count, and the lack of other options means that he can have quite a variety of shapes.
On this sequence, the doubler has doubled at the two level and again at the four level. That means that his minimum is rather higher. He is also more likely to have a pure takeout double, because he chose to double rather than overcall 2NT or a suit.
On this hand, I bid 5♦, but I think it fairly close. However, in neither auction do I think that balanced hands should always pass.
... that would still not be conclusive proof, before someone wants to explain that to me as well as if I was a 5 year-old. - gwnn
(2h)- X - (4h) - p - (p)- X - (p)- ?