skaeran, on Sep 19 2009, 12:02 AM, said:
I agree on your last part. But then it belongs in the B/I forum. A/E players should know what first action to make after a 1♣ opening holding an absolutely normal t/o double.
The given auction in itself would indeed present an interesting problem if our hand fitted a 1♦ overcall.
I'd suggest not revealing the complete hand when that makes the whole auction ridiculous. It should be good enough if asked to tell that the auction was a total mess, which created an interesting problem.
Well, i disagree.
1) Only two posters seems to support this, while many, and indeed some of the respected posters, seems to have no problem.
2) My opening post has attracted 30 comments directly discussing the stated problem. This is far above average for this forum.
3) Opinions has been discerning in this forum, so it seems to me it was worth discussing.
I only revealed the full deal out of politeness, because somebody asked for it.
(1♣) - 1♦ - (Pass) - Pass
( X ) - Pass - (Pass) - 1♥
( X ) - ???
First double was take-out (might be flawed). Second double was penalty.
Feel free to comment on IMP's too.