gitmo closure
#1
Posted 2009-May-20, 10:53
#2
Posted 2009-May-20, 11:08
You've gotten so bitter since the election. You used to at least pretend to contribute original content. Now you just post pissy little one or two line rants and then fade off in that gentle night...
For what its worth, I do think that Congress are acting like a bunch of gutless wonders. I genuinely wish that more of them would have balls to stand up and do the right thing. (As I recall, one Senator made a speach saying that he thought that his State should being willing to take the detainees)
I don't use the expression "idiots" because I think that they are making a quite rational political calculation regarding the intelligence of the average voter. (Somehow, voters are willing to tolerate well organized and very violent narcotics trafficers in their communites, but god forbid anyone should have to put up with a "terrorist")
As for the FBI... Arguing that terrorist's should be moved into US jails has a very big downside and (essentially) no personal upside. That's why its admirable (and more than a bit surprising) when a politican like Obama is willing to take a principled stand and do the right thing.
Kind of sad when you just see it as an opportunity to make yet another poorly conceived mocking post.
#3
Posted 2009-May-20, 11:12
#4
Posted 2009-May-20, 11:41
luke warm, on May 20 2009, 08:12 PM, said:
Says the forum's epitome of sweetness and light,
whose very fart's bear the odor of fresh flowers...
#5
Posted 2009-May-20, 11:52
Just sent them home. Then the congressmen also don't risk the embarrassment of having them in a prison within their own electoral district.
Not that it would be fortunate to release a bunch of criminals but that's the normal procedure when the police can't charge them within the time frame.
#6
Posted 2009-May-20, 12:32
helene_t, on May 20 2009, 05:52 PM, said:
Just sent them home. Then the congressmen also don't risk the embarrassment of having them in a prison within their own electoral district.
Not that it would be fortunate to release a bunch of criminals but that's the normal procedure when the police can't charge them within the time frame.
Citing the law ... how quaint.
#7
Posted 2009-May-20, 12:47
Are we going to start applying Panamanian law to them next?
THE CRIMINAL CODE DOES NOT APPLY.
"gwnn" said:
hanp does not always mean literally what he writes.
#8
Posted 2009-May-20, 18:21
vuroth, on May 20 2009, 01:47 PM, said:
Are we going to start applying Panamanian law to them next?
THE CRIMINAL CODE DOES NOT APPLY.
Habeus Corpus is not specifically American Law - but it applies to foreigners. The Geneva Convention is American Law because it is a signed treaty - but it applies to foreigners - captured on foreign soil.
#9
Posted 2009-May-20, 21:53
vuroth, on May 20 2009, 01:47 PM, said:
Are we going to start applying Panamanian law to them next?
THE CRIMINAL CODE DOES NOT APPLY.
I am not a lawyer, but I am virtually certain you are mistaken.
As for tv, screw it. You aren't missing anything. -- Ken Berg
Our ultimate goal on defense is to know by trick two or three everyone's hand at the table. -- Mike777
I have come to realise it is futile to expect or hope a regular club game will be run in accordance with the laws. -- Jillybean
#10
Posted 2009-May-21, 01:18
luke warm, on May 20 2009, 11:53 AM, said:
Because it's the FBI director saying it, he must be right...
#11
Posted 2009-May-21, 04:06
cherdanno, on May 21 2009, 02:18 AM, said:
well the senate voted 90 - 6 against, also... so it was more than him worried about it... the thing is, are they right or is obama?
#12
Posted 2009-May-21, 06:03
luke warm, on May 21 2009, 01:06 PM, said:
cherdanno, on May 21 2009, 02:18 AM, said:
well the senate voted 90 - 6 against, also... so it was more than him worried about it... the thing is, are they right or is obama?
Your "right" versus "wrong" construction assumes that the actors share the same set of motivations. Some would call the construction simplistic or, more charitably, Manichean.
I suspect that the Senators are doing the "right" thing to get reelected. I think that "Obama is doing the "right" thing to improve the United State's positioning in the world at large.
Personally, I tend to worry much more about the US's international position.
I really don't care much whether Senator XYZ happens to get relected.
Therefore, I tend to sympathize with Obama.
Which is not to say that I think that Obama necessarily handled this situation correctly. It's entirely possible that the failure to provide more details about HOW the detainees would be transferred to the US mattered more than the fact THAT the detainees would be transferred to the US.
Once the bulk of the Senator's are able to see that the detainees are going to be sent off to east bumblefuck Idaho and won't be anywhere near their precious constituents we might see some major changes in the voting patterns.
#13
Posted 2009-May-21, 06:48
- Who cares if the detainees go to East Bumblefuck or to the backyards of senator xyz's favorite voter? Mainland US has open internal borders. Now sending them to Hawaii or Puerto Rico might give extra safety for some.
- Are these guys dangerous? I guess some of them are. I guess some of them have just followed instructions from their commanders and would not be the kind of criminals who would shoot at random citizens if they managed to escape from a prison, or cause major problems within the prison. Anyway, there are already hundreds of thousands in mainland US prisons, some of whom are probably dangerous. Has it ever been suggested sending American hard core criminals to Guantanamo?
- What is unacceptable is that they are kept for months without being prosecuted, and I suppose some have been treated badly in various ways. Who cares if it takes place in Guantanamo or in the US mainland? It was mentioned on the site Jimmy linked to that they might be put in supermax prisons if transfered to the mainland. Great.
#14
Posted 2009-May-21, 06:57
helene_t, on May 21 2009, 03:48 PM, said:
- Who cares if the detainees go to East Bumblefuck or to the backyards of senator xyz's favorite voter? Mainland US has open internal borders. Now sending them to Hawaii or Puerto Rico might give extra safety for some.
Do you know the acronymn "NIMBY" ?
#15
Posted 2009-May-21, 08:29
A notable conservative, Bruce Fein argues that our criminal courts are totally adequate for this challenge:
Quote
He told IPS, "Shortly after 9/11, Michael Chertoff, then head of the Criminal Division of DOJ, testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee that Article III federal courts have performed brilliantly in the trials of terrorism cases assisted by the Classified Information Procedures Act of 1980 (CIPA)."
CIPA enables trials without disclosing national security secrets where a summary of the incriminating evidence is sufficient to enable the accused to conduct a fair defense.
Fein says Chertoff told the Senate Judiciary Committee that "the history of this government in prosecuting terrorists in domestic courts has been one of unmitigated success and one in which the judges have done a superb job of managing the courtroom and not compromising our concerns about security and our concerns about classified information."
The actions of 9-11 were committed by a finite number of operators and co-conspirators, yet the U.S. has expanded the definition of who was to blame to include all terrorists and terrorist supporters, which includes virtually everyone who disagrees with U.S. self-granted right of empire.
Those who fought back in Iraq against an illegal invasion and occupation of their country were first called insurgents and then later re-named al-Qaeda in Iraq.
If we had not invaded, would there be an al-Qaeda in Iraq to demonize and imprison?
#16
Posted 2009-May-21, 08:34
Winstonm, on May 21 2009, 03:29 PM, said:
Sounds plausible. Otherwise just lock them up in Hilbert's Hotel. No excuse for not closing gitmo.
#17
Posted 2009-May-21, 09:58
helene_t, on May 21 2009, 09:34 AM, said:
Winstonm, on May 21 2009, 03:29 PM, said:
I only flirted with being a math major for one semester, but I'm pretty sure the number of all terrorists and terrorist supporters in the world is finite, too.
Call me Desdinova...Eternal Light
C. It's the nexus of the crisis and the origin of storms.
IV: ace 333: pot should be game, idk
e: "Maybe God remembered how cute you were as a carrot."
#18
Posted 2009-May-21, 10:06
Lobowolf, on May 21 2009, 10:58 AM, said:
helene_t, on May 21 2009, 09:34 AM, said:
Winstonm, on May 21 2009, 03:29 PM, said:
I only flirted with being a math major for one semester, but I'm pretty sure the number of all terrorists and terrorist supporters in the world is finite, too.
I'm sorry, but you are wrong - didn't you watch Fluffy's video about Muslims taking over the world by reproduction? Obviously, if there are new terrorists born every second we can't possible keep up and therefore there number is not finite.
This probably explains why we target Pakistan and Afghan wedding parties with our drones.
#19
Posted 2009-May-21, 10:08
#20
Posted 2009-May-21, 10:11
Quote
I stand here today as someone whose own life was made possible by these documents. My father came to our shores in search of the promise that they offered. My mother made me rise before dawn to learn of their truth when I lived as a child in a foreign land. My own American journey was paved by generations of citizens who gave meaning to those simple words – "to form a more perfect union." I have studied the Constitution as a student; I have taught it as a teacher; I have been bound by it as a lawyer and legislator. I took an oath to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution as Commander-in-Chief, and as a citizen, I know that we must never – ever – turn our back on its enduring principles for expedience sake.
I make this claim not simply as a matter of idealism. We uphold our most cherished values not only because doing so is right, but because it strengthens our country and keeps us safe. Time and again, our values have been our best national security asset – in war and peace; in times of ease and in eras of upheaval.
Obama shares the principles of all real Americans, democrats and republicans. Contrast the pettiness and sleaziness of his opponents (from both major parties) on this issue.
The infliction of cruelty with a good conscience is a delight to moralists — that is why they invented hell. — Bertrand Russell

Help
