Thanks, Helene, I found it. Studies from Minnesota, no less! Here is an article:
En-twinned lives.
Quote
SKEPTIC: Next, let's look at religious beliefs and political attitudes. Again, the conventional wisdom is that if you grow up in an affluent area you tend to be a conservative Republican, while in another demographic area you tend to be a liberal Democrat. If you grow up in one home, you'd be Roman Catholic, but in another home you'd be Jewish, or Fundamentalist, or practice no religion at all. Especially in America today, religion and politics are very entwined and very important to how we lead our lives. How much do genes count here?
NS: When it comes to religiosity we've shown that degree of commitment and religious activity, regardless of denomination, have a genetic component. But denomination seems not to. One of the most informative and compelling cases is that of Oskar and Jack, two MZ twins, one raised by his father as Jewish in Trinidad, the other by his mother as Catholic in Nazi Germany. When I spoke to Jack a couple of years ago he said that they both recognized that had they been switched they would have grown up with the other's political, religious, and historical understandings.
Both realized they were in situations where if the people around them had known their true identity they wouldn't have been very well liked. Jack was in British-ruled Trinidad, hiding his German roots. Oskar was in Nazi Germany hiding his Jewish roots. So they both became fanatical in the sense of embracing the culture and beliefs of their particular country, which I think they would have done if their positions had been switched. It's very interesting to consider that, as Jack put it, "If we had been switched, I would have taken Oskar's place for sure. It doesn't bother me. But I'm glad I'm not on the other side" (p. 77, in Segal, 2007).
Identical twins raised separately gave similar answers to general questions about religion even when raised in families with different belief systems. Fraternal twins not so much.
So if you have an identical twin, his or her general answers will tend to be similar to yours. Otherwise, not so much, even among siblings. The specific religion one adopts depends upon environmental influences.
This post has been edited by PassedOut: 2009-May-15, 08:15
The growth of wisdom may be gauged exactly by the diminution of ill temper. — Friedrich Nietzsche
The infliction of cruelty with a good conscience is a delight to moralists — that is why they invented hell. — Bertrand Russell