blackshoe, on May 7 2009, 09:13 PM, said:
Robert Heinlein wrote Starship Troopers in 1952. It was a controversial, but very interesting (to me, anyway, and to a lot of other science fiction fans) book.
It's a sermon with a plot attached. You probably have a different look on it than I, as a former career Navy man.
Certainly, Harry Harrison had a different look on it than most. I'm not saying it's a bad book, here - it's just if you try to read it just as a story, you're going to be screaming at it, unless he's preaching to the choir.
Quote
When Paul Verhoeven directed the 1997 movie version of the story, he completely mangled Heinlein's ideas. ... I hated it. So did a lot of other people. Ginny Heinlein, the author's widow, reputedly said, after seeing it, that "it sucks". I dunno. I wasn't there. She was an outspoken woman, I understand, but that particular term doesn't seem to me like one she would have used, from what little I know of her.
The best comment I have seen about the movie is "based on the back cover of a book by Heinlein." I'm told, however, if you don't actually know the book, it's a pretty good action movie. Unfortunately, I know the book, and I read it again every couple of years to see if I still disagree with it as violently as I used to.
Quote
But anyway, the point is that SF, particularly in movies, often sacrifices quality story for action and special effects. A shame really, but there it is.
You should read
this guy's articles - among other things,
he has an article that talks specifically about "why do SF movie adaptations suck?" - and a lot of his argument is that by and large, all book adaptations "suck" the same way, there's not much you can do about it because of the translation, it's just that SFnals are almost 100% "read the book, and care", which makes us different from everybody else.