Have you read the torture memos?
#1
Posted 2009-April-18, 01:15
#2
Posted 2009-April-18, 05:24
The infliction of cruelty with a good conscience is a delight to moralists — that is why they invented hell. — Bertrand Russell
#3
Posted 2009-April-18, 06:01
Not our (The United States) finest moment
#4
Posted 2009-April-18, 08:14
At the same time, Obama should be castigated for these statements:
Quote
And Greenwald takes Obama and the politcal elite to task:
Quote
And I would add this: every successful prosecution of every crime is a product of "spending our time and energy laying blame for the past." Shall we adopt the same Obama Credo for murder, rape, thievery, and terrorism? What is there about the political elite that makes their actions immune from prosecution and the advocates of prosecution "forces that divide us"?
I have said it before. We are either a nation of the rule of law or the sway of man; if not the rule of law, then we should abandon our false claim of Republic.
#5
Posted 2009-April-18, 08:28
Winstonm, on Apr 18 2009, 09:14 AM, said:
At the same time, Obama should be castigated for these statements:
While I agree that the leaders who authorized torture should be prosecuted, I disagree that Obama should be castigated for his statements.
Obama has to govern a country containing many fearful citizens who agree that people should be tortured under certain circumstances and who supported the Bush actions wholeheartedly. As distasteful as compromised principles might be to all of us, one must remain practical to have any hope of governing.
Note that this cuts both ways. People who strongly believe that abortion is tantamount to murder must compromise those beliefs when in the government.
The infliction of cruelty with a good conscience is a delight to moralists — that is why they invented hell. — Bertrand Russell
#6
Posted 2009-April-18, 08:38
Quote
You are entitled to your opinion, of course. I am still firmly in the Greenwald camp. As far as I am concerned, those citizens who were fervently in favor of torture are as guilty as the instigators themselves.
Although I strongly disagree with the policies, I do not think Reagan or Bush the Lesser should be prosecuted for adopting supply-side economics and cutting corporate taxes.
Torture is not a policiy decision - it is a crime. Either our political elite are above the law or they are not. It really is that simple.
#7
Posted 2009-April-18, 08:51
Obama specifically ruled out prosecuting CIA officials who were just following orders. He has left the door open to prosecute the government officials who were responsible for crafting the policies that sanction and promoted torture as US policy.
Personally, I think that the best course of of action would be to stand by and let the International Criminal Court start war crimes trials against Yoo, Addington, and the like. (Honestly, I think that said trials should extend up to at least the level of the office of the Vice President)
If it were up to me, I'd hand all of the accused over to the International Criminal Court if/when charges are brought to bear. I doubt that Obama would make the same decision.
#8
Posted 2009-April-18, 09:01
Winstonm, on Apr 18 2009, 09:14 AM, said:
I have said it before. We are either a nation of the rule of law or the sway of man; if not the rule of law, then we should abandon our false claim of Republic.
hmm....somehow I dont think Hayden has done too much howling on MSNBC unless he has been doing it on Morning Joe. Joe was making such a big thing about the caterpillar in a box thing that I had to turn him off friday morning.
#9
Posted 2009-April-18, 09:39
Everyone knows that Bush and his staff violated international law. Having that confirmed once again is not sending any message to anyone.
What the U.S. government and U.S. legal system needs is to demonstrate to the U.S. public that these guys violated U.S. law and that they aren't above the law.
#10
Posted 2009-April-18, 10:09
The bigger problem, to my mind, is the fact that we in the US let people who would do these things gain office in the first place. By releasing these documents, Obama has made it impossible for citizens to claim ignorance of what crimes have been done in our names. Transparency is not the answer to everything, but it certainly is crucial in allowing people to vote intelligently.
I'm willing to let this play out over time. Let folks digest what has been done. Prosecutions instigated by grass-roots demands will be a lot more effective than if Obama seems to be exacting political retribution.
To me, though, the commentators who say that Obama is another Bush are just plain nuts.
The infliction of cruelty with a good conscience is a delight to moralists — that is why they invented hell. — Bertrand Russell
#11
Posted 2009-April-18, 10:48
Quote
The escalation to especially brutal interrogation tactics against the prisoner, Abu Zubaydah, including confining him in boxes and slamming him against the wall, was ordered by officials at C.I.A. headquarters based on a highly inflated assessment of his importance, interviews and a review of newly released documents show.
Abu Zubaydah had provided much valuable information under less severe treatment, and the harsher handling produced no breakthroughs, according to one former intelligence official with direct knowledge of the case. Instead, watching his torment caused great distress to his captors, the official said.
The infliction of cruelty with a good conscience is a delight to moralists — that is why they invented hell. — Bertrand Russell
#12
Posted 2009-April-18, 10:51
helene_t, on Apr 18 2009, 06:39 PM, said:
Everyone knows that Bush and his staff violated international law. Having that confirmed once again is not sending any message to anyone.
What the U.S. government and U.S. legal system needs is to demonstrate to the U.S. public that these guys violated U.S. law and that they aren't above the law.
The fact that Cheney + Co violated US law doesn't mean that they didn't violate International Law. I think that War Crimes should fall "up" and be tried at the highest level possible.
It's also unclear whether or not it would be possible to try Cheney, etc. within the US.
#13
Posted 2009-April-18, 11:53
helene_t, on Apr 18 2009, 10:39 AM, said:
Having them convicted and punished would send a message, wouldn't it?
#14
Posted 2009-April-18, 14:32
Quote
I strongly agree with these sentiments. I am also optimistic enough about my country to believe the vast majority of the population despises the concept of torture and believes it to never be justified. I also think there is a loud and vocal and very small minority who think like thugs and schoolyard bullies and who curl a lip, sneer, and say, "So?" to any contradiction to their appetite for vengeance. Unfortunately, this same small group seems to have a lot of the power of the media right now and their claims are heard disproportionately to what is in the heart of most Americans.
Along the same lines, it is shameful to me that an author of one of these memos is now a Federal judge, appointed by Bush: Judge Jay S. Bybee.
Quote
#15
Posted 2009-April-18, 15:38
They convict for international bribery. (where they can)
They can convict for international terrorism. (no matter to whom it was directed)
As long as the individual is subject to the law of the land, enforce it or change it. Equal application of the law is what counts.
#16
Posted 2009-April-18, 17:27
Quote
Yup. I don't get the argument that Bush, Cheney & Co. did this stuff and the rest of us are somehow innocent. These are U.S. policies, U.S. decisions and U.S. actions. We let these creeps get into office and we let them stay in office for 8 years. We all have blood on our hands.
#17
Posted 2009-April-18, 18:24
PassedOut, on Apr 18 2009, 09:28 AM, said:
Winstonm, on Apr 18 2009, 09:14 AM, said:
At the same time, Obama should be castigated for these statements:
While I agree that the leaders who authorized torture should be prosecuted, I disagree that Obama should be castigated for his statements.
i think you and winston both miss the mark on this one... have you ever considered that obama isn't even slightly interested in any kind of criminal prosecution against the previous admin (most especially bush and/or cheney) because he himself might covet the same power (or at least see the potential for having to use it) without fear of future criminal retribution?
hrothgar, on Apr 18 2009, 09:51 AM, said:
and i think this is ridiculous... of course i do understand that many in america want to hasten the day when we're all one, when any pretense of an american sovereignty is a thing of the past
#18
Posted 2009-April-18, 18:45
Quote
Of course. That is exactly the reason his further statements should be castigated. Regardless of whether or not he wishes to hold onto the same power, he is only the President so it is not up to his whim to keep what is not his to start.
Quote
Then you must hold the position that the President and all the executive branch is above the law and there are no checks and balances on that power.
#19
Posted 2009-April-18, 19:06
#20
Posted 2009-April-18, 19:11
pigpenz, on Apr 18 2009, 08:06 PM, said:
Who is "they", and where did this arrest take place?
As for tv, screw it. You aren't missing anything. -- Ken Berg
Our ultimate goal on defense is to know by trick two or three everyone's hand at the table. -- Mike777
I have come to realise it is futile to expect or hope a regular club game will be run in accordance with the laws. -- Jillybean

Help
