In the auction :
1C - 1H - X - P
2S - ,
would 2S show a hand that would have raised a 1S response to 2S absent the intervention, or would it show a stronger hand since opener could have bid 1S?
Page 1 of 1
What does 2S mean here
#1
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:09
Alle Menschen werden bruder.
Where were you while we were getting high?
Where were you while we were getting high?
#2
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:14
Stronger, although I'd say not as strong as e.g. 1m-1M-3M in an unconstested auction.
#3
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:16
By agreement and I'm assuming that x = exactly 4♠.
Some play that 2♠ shows more than a minimum and 1♠ shows a dead minimum.
A better agreement is that 1♠ shows 3 cards and 2♠ is 4 cards and any minimum.
Some play that 2♠ shows more than a minimum and 1♠ shows a dead minimum.
A better agreement is that 1♠ shows 3 cards and 2♠ is 4 cards and any minimum.
Hi y'all!
Winner - BBO Challenge bracket #6 - February, 2017.
Winner - BBO Challenge bracket #6 - February, 2017.
#4
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:19
Stronger than 1♠, but not strong enough to cuebid 2♥... Usually a hand that would have jumped to 3♠ over a 1♠ response imo.
Yay for the "Ignored Users" feature!
#5
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:20
Yes, I should clarify that X there showed 4 spades
Alle Menschen werden bruder.
Where were you while we were getting high?
Where were you while we were getting high?
#6
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:22
It's by agreement, neither way is really standard in the sense you could assume it with a good random partner. I would say Adam's way is the old fashioned way and Phil's is the more modern way, and people are trending more to it. I agree with him that it's better.
Edit: Just to clarify, the Adam to whom I referred was mtvesuvius, not awm. And the Phil was Phil.
Edit: Just to clarify, the Adam to whom I referred was mtvesuvius, not awm. And the Phil was Phil.
Please let me know about any questions or interest or bug reports about GIB.
#7
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:22
For me, 1♠ is normally three spades or a 4333 hand. In either case it will often be that spades is not our best contract (4333 hands sometimes play better in notrump despite 4-4 fit).
The jump to 2♠ shows four-card support and also indicates suitability for playing in spades. This doesn't really show extras, although I suppose a 4(23)4 twelve-count is now better than a minimum because of the trump fit and the doubleton.
The jump to 2♠ shows four-card support and also indicates suitability for playing in spades. This doesn't really show extras, although I suppose a 4(23)4 twelve-count is now better than a minimum because of the trump fit and the doubleton.
Adam W. Meyerson
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#8
Posted 2009-March-04, 17:25
Great stuff! Thanks.
Alle Menschen werden bruder.
Where were you while we were getting high?
Where were you while we were getting high?
#9
Posted 2009-March-04, 23:48
qwery_hi, on Mar 4 2009, 06:09 PM, said:
In the auction :
1C - 1H - X - P
2S - ,
would 2S show a hand that would have raised a 1S response to 2S absent the intervention, or would it show a stronger hand since opener could have bid 1S?
1C - 1H - X - P
2S - ,
would 2S show a hand that would have raised a 1S response to 2S absent the intervention, or would it show a stronger hand since opener could have bid 1S?
Nonexpert response:
1) I would assume x=4spades..very very often
2) I would assume jump to 2s =around 16-18....and 4s.
3) I would assume with 3s and minimum partner is stuck trying her best to not bid one spade.
#10
Posted 2009-March-05, 14:56
The old fashioned way is that 2♠ is stronger than 1♠. And that's how I've played it for ages.
These days I've changed to 1♠=3, 2♠=4. Normally I play the double as 4+ spades, but I'd play the same responses from opener even if double shows exactly 4.
These days I've changed to 1♠=3, 2♠=4. Normally I play the double as 4+ spades, but I'd play the same responses from opener even if double shows exactly 4.
Kind regards,
Harald
Harald
Page 1 of 1

Help
