A puzzling BI thread.
Quote
I'm sure Roland is looking for the technically best line.
If that is the case then I think that cashing the ace-king of clubs and then finessing in diamonds might be the best line.
However, it worries me that LHO lead from a 3-card heart suit against 1NT-3NT. Also, maybe if we take the diamond finesse immediately the opponents may not take 4 spade tricks if it loses and we can try clubs later?
Roland wasn't looking for expert input but I'd like to hear from pretty much anybody to see how they would play it. It is an interesting and difficult hand. I think I will still go for the technically best line because LHO almost surely has 7+ cards in the minors. Maybe I missed something really obvious though, not getting a BI problem makes me very uncomfortable.
Quote
South opened 1NT and was raised to 3. Although North is 3433 I think he should have used Stayman. Opener does indeed promise a balanced hand, but he could easily have a worthless doubleton in one of the black suits. He had as you see, and 4♥ is a much better contract than 3NT.
FWIW I like the 3NT bid. Sure, if I had known that partner has 4 hearts and a weak doubleton in a black suit then I would have played in 4H, but more often partner either does not have 4 hearts, or partner does and 3NT is still at least as good a contract. It is hard to estimate how much the information we give away by bidding Stayman costs, I think it is a significant enough downside to bid 3NT. And of course the fact that this time partner did have this hand does not prove anything. Whatever decision you make is going to cost you sometimes, the only difference is that if you bid stayman and you went down because of the extra information you gave the opponents, you might never know.
and the result can be plotted on a graph.
S: 3NT
Lead: H4