What does partner promise or maybe sacrifice?
#1
Posted 2009-February-19, 18:30
♠ AT876
♥ K5
♦ 953
♣ 962
Partner opens 4♥, RHO bids 5♣... Your bid?
#2
Posted 2009-February-19, 18:51
#3
Posted 2009-February-19, 18:59
#4
Posted 2009-February-19, 19:00
It seems overly optimistic to hope for 2 tricks defensively with this hand unless we are counting some tricks in partner's hand.
Although I do expect partner to furnish enough defensive cards to defeat 5♣.
With very little more I think it would be clear to bid 5♥. With the actual hand I am inclined to bid - only if both contracts are failing am I making a big mistake. And if I make that mistake by bidding then I still might get a good score if the opponents make the same mistake and take a phantom favourable vulnerability dive in 6minor.
I believe that the USA currently hold only the World Championship For People Who Still Bid Like Your Auntie Gladys - dburn
dunno how to play 4 card majors - JLOGIC
True but I know Standard American and what better reason could I have for playing Precision? - Hideous Hog
Bidding is an estimation of probabilities SJ Simon
#5
Posted 2009-February-19, 19:04
#6
Posted 2009-February-19, 19:27
5♥ for me opposite a very sound r/w preempter (me).
Winner - BBO Challenge bracket #6 - February, 2017.
#7
Posted 2009-February-19, 19:31
Perhaps it does partly depend on what you expect for partner's R/W 4♥, but I don't expect him to have 9 tricks in his own hand, and I don't expect to make 11 tricks in hearts.
I don't know how many tricks they make - 10, 11, 12?
So, because I don't expect to make, I pass and hope the preempt has done it's work.
I wonder if the tendency is to bid 5/5 more often on the forums than in real life, because, after all, the hand has been posted as a problem - why should the boring normal action be right?
#8
Posted 2009-February-19, 19:37
655321, on Feb 19 2009, 08:31 PM, said:
Actually I think the opposite is true.
Winner - BBO Challenge bracket #6 - February, 2017.
#9
Posted 2009-February-19, 19:37
#10
Posted 2009-February-19, 20:28
Can we defeat 5♣?, kinda unlikelly, RHO didn't double, this translates that we are not very likely to score a spade ruff from partner. since going for more than 500 sounds weird and we might sometimes make our game I like 5♥.
At MPs 5♥ is not the % action at all.
#11
Posted 2009-February-20, 13:39
jdonn, on Feb 20 2009, 02:37 AM, said:
Agree.
Harald
#12
Posted 2009-February-20, 13:50
If PD has a useful side honor we could have 3 tricks on defence but still need to get some help from the ♠ suit to make 5♥. If PD has no help outside of ♥ we are going -500 too often for my tastes.

Help
