Psyching
#1
Posted 2003-November-24, 05:13
Even if it's not in the rules, this won't get rid of the block in people's minds. Anyone have any idea to approach people who think psyching is cheating?
BTW, the reason why I psyched on the hand was because we needed a swing in order to win the match, and the hand looked right for it. We achieved a good score on the hand.
#2
Posted 2003-November-24, 05:26
http://forums.bridgebase.com/in...ay;threadid=576
#3
Posted 2003-November-24, 08:51
With this said and done, the event organizers also have an obligation to to publish the conditions of contest. I personally have no interest lending even tacit support to events that prohibit psyches or regulate conventions. Furthermore, I get extremely annoyed when event organizers seem to be making up the regulations as they go along. Case in point: Yesterday there was a tournament on BBO in which a variety of treatments including Polish Club, Multi, and Canape were all explictly banned in the Conditions of Contest. I think that the event organizers followed exactly the right proceedures by explictly describing the rules under which they wanted to run their event.
As to your specific example: I am not aware of any Zonal authority that bans player's from psyching in first/second seat.
#4
Posted 2003-November-24, 09:38
Having said that, a few common sense rules and a few codified rules exist.
First, it is illegal to pschye a strong forcing opening bid (although 2C as "either GF" or "preempt in diamond" is legal, as this is not a pscyh but a multi-meaning bid).
Second, it is not legal to basically pyche so often as to destroy the continuity of the game. To psyche 4 hands out of ten, for instance seems excessive to me. I think 2 psyhces per 24 boards is a very reasonable rate for some who "psyhces frequentlly"
Third, if you make the same type of psyches in the same type of position so often that your partner "picks it up" and takes it into account, you pysch may be illegal and at best iil advised based upon ethics.
Fourth, if the person running the contest you are competing in establishes prior to the event that pscyhs are not allowed, then they are not allowed. Of course this has to be conveyed to everyone.
Fifth, for an experienced partnership to pscych against a pickup partnership in on line bridge is just bad form. They have virtually no experience togehter and such a psych has an unethical feel to me... no matter how perfect the hand is for the pysch. Others will disagree with me on this issue I know. Against good opposition or establish opponents, when the right hand come up, psyche away .
Psyches are a necessary part of good bridge. Choosing when to psych, based upon the bidding so far, the vulnerability, your holding, the state of the match or your possition in a tournment, is a difficult skill to master. One might choose to pass with a good hand. One might choose to preempt in a four card suit, or with a fairly strong hand iwth 8 card suit. One might choose a splinter in a suit with three small cards. One might open 1NT on nothing, or open 1 of a suit with one card in it or 5 cards but no hcp. These psyches are often like the unilateral very light preempt, or a preempt with a side four card major. When they work, they work, when they don't they really dont. It is a roll of the dice. It is this "top-bottom" nature of the psche that makes frequent pscyhes unsporting, especially in a matchpoint game. You are randomly giving tops and bottoms to your opponents. IF it is late in an event and you are "out of contention" I would say it is unethical to psyche... you may reward someone "unfairly" or harm them "unfairly". I use unfairly in teh context that you are creating a random outcome on a hand where no matter if your psych works or not, it will not help you finish high in the ranking. Again, others will disagree with me. I know several people who go psych happy when they have a bad game, and play down the middle when they have a good game... I think this is not sporting.
#5
Posted 2003-November-24, 09:53
Many people I would think that tend to play bridge in between the proverbial lines feel that psyching destroys the intergrity of the game. However, I think that psyching, if done with randomness, and done at specific times, can equalize a deficit. It's all a matter of style.
Remember too folks, more often than now, psyching is losing bridge. Give you a great example from this weekend:
RHO opens this hand 2NT:
Ax A ATX AKT9xxx
To me, this isn't quite a psyche. It's an offshape Nt that if they hit partner with a minimum, they sit pretty, and has a place to run, clubs. So far, so good. Problem is, BOTH partners decided to somehow get themselves into 7C redoubled down four!
However, a funny story to show you more often than not, psychnig is losing bridge....
RHO opens 1S on this lovely hand:
VOID Qxxx J8xx Txxxx
LHO not in on the act, goes straight to 4S on this:
76543 Jxx 9x 8xx
Pass, Pass, DOUBLE! RHO now runs into clubs, exposing the psyche, let's just say, down 7 vulnerable doubled was quite nice.
Whether we like it or not, psyching is allowed, and part of the game. It's up to us to expose them and make life heck on them.
#6
Posted 2003-November-24, 10:01
Maybe within the ACBL. Thankfully that "ogust" [sic] body doesn't actually have any authority in online bridge. Psyching strong forcing openings is perfect legitimate in WBF play. I recall at least one appeal involving this very issue. For anyone who cares, the current WBF regulations regarding psyches is available at
http://www.worldbridge.org/departments/sys...ems/psyches.asp
#7
Posted 2003-November-24, 10:07
Quote
Many people I would think that tend to play bridge in between the proverbial lines feel that psyching destroys the intergrity of the game. However, I think that psyching, if done with randomness, and done at specific times, can equalize a deficit. It's all a matter of style.
Remember too folks, more often than now, psyching is losing bridge. Give you a great example from this weekend:
RHO opens this hand 2NT:
Ax A ATX AKT9xxx
To me, this isn't quite a psyche. It's an offshape Nt that if they hit partner with a minimum, they sit pretty, and has a place to run, clubs. So far, so good. Problem is, BOTH partners decided to somehow get themselves into 7C redoubled down four!
However, a funny story to show you more often than not, psychnig is losing bridge....
RHO opens 1S on this lovely hand:
VOID Qxxx J8xx Txxxx
LHO not in on the act, goes straight to 4S on this:
76543 Jxx 9x 8xx
Pass, Pass, DOUBLE! RHO now runs into clubs, exposing the psyche, let's just say, down 7 vulnerable doubled was quite nice.
Whether we like it or not, psyching is allowed, and part of the game. It's up to us to expose them and make life heck on them.
Random psiches are a normal part of the game and are used for bridge reasons and for psychological reasons too. Banning psyches is equivalent in my opinion to banning squeezes. If you like to play a sub-version of this game just because the whole stuff is too much for your brain power then don't call it bridge....
#8
Posted 2003-November-24, 10:36
Quote
Maybe within the ACBL. Thankfully that "ogust" [sic] body doesn't actually have any authority in online bridge. Psyching strong forcing openings is perfect legitimate in WBF play. I recall at least one appeal involving this very issue. For anyone who cares, the current WBF regulations regarding psyches is available at
http://www.worldbridge.org/departments/sys...ems/psyches.asp
Well. it is clearly illegal in the ACBL, but it is my understanding that psyching a conventional, strong forcing opening bid is also illegal in WBL sanctioned events. Here I will quote The ORANGE BOOK )updated to September 2002)
HANDBOOK OF EBU DIRECTIVES AND PERMITTED CONVENTIONS
This rule book says
"6.1.13 You may not psyche a game forcing or nearly game forcing
artificial opening. Thus, for example, you may not psyche an
Acol 2 opening or a Benjamin opening 2 or 2. In addition you
may not psyche a Multi-2 opening in a Level 3 event (see 13.4.2).
Reading the orange book, I found another illegal psych I never heard before:
"6.1.4 Watson: a double of 3NT asks your partner not to lead the suit
you've bid: you may not use this if you have psyched."
#9
Posted 2003-November-24, 11:33
The Orange Book is a publication of the English Bridge Union.
The EBU another example of a National Organization.
Here, once again, the WBF regulations are independant of the EBU.
#10
Posted 2003-November-24, 13:28
Quote
The Orange Book is a publication of the English Bridge Union.
The EBU another example of a National Organization.
Here, once again, the WBF regulations are independant of the EBU.
Well, the intenational laws are not so wide open. Let's examine a few of them. From the International Laws, we find?"
"LAW 40-A. Right to Choose Call or Play
A player may make any call or play (including an intentionally misleading call == such as a psychic bid == or a call or play that departs from commonly
accepted, or previously announced, use of a convention), without prior announcement, provided that such call or play is not based on a partnership
understanding."
This seems to be what you are eluding too in that the International laws are more flexible than those of certain nationalities. However, the international laws potential take away what they give in 40-A just a few paragraphs later where it says...
"Law 40-D. Regulation of Conventions
The sponsoring organisation may regulate the use of bidding or play conventions. Zonal organisations may, in addition, regulate partnership understandings (even if not conventional) that permit the partnerships initial actions at the one level to be made with a hand of a King or more below average strength. Zonal organisations may delegate this responsibility"
This means that under international law of bridge, conventions CAN BE limited to a king more or below the average stregth if they like if you are going to use a conention. Think of this like Condition of contest for BBO tournments, where you admit the tournmnet organizer/director, can establish the conditions of contest. Here the world organization allows pschyes, but 40-D allows limitation on psyhces of conventions.
They can even REGULATE which convention to be used (they could, outlaw for an event, multi-2D, for instance). This is codified in the laws. The laws do not say any particular thing is outlawed or illegal, but it could be by event. As you well know in the US, some tournments allow an anything goes attitude, some adhere to the CCG thingee.
What about in WBF event (instead of leaving it up to the organizers?). Most people reading this post has never played in a WBF event. These are BY INVINTATION only, so holding that they allow brown and red sticker conventions as well as highly unusual methods as an example for all others is disingenious.
For one thing, even in WBF world championship events, it is not ANY GOES. In Monte Carlo, for instance, The World Seniors Bowl and the
World Transnational Open Teams where both Category 3 events, thus no High unusual methods or Brown Sticker systems were permitted. In addition, any pairs competing in those two events who wanted to play Red Sticker systems had to register these in advance and required the approval of the Chairman of the Systems Committee.
For the Bermuda Bowl and Venice cup, it was system I with pretty much anything goes. However, bear in mind that a) all the players in the event are of the absolute highest quality skillwise.
And yet you advocate allowing such things as normal and "allowed" by WBF. Yet the page you list even identifies some as brown sticker (like an explicit agreements that psychic calls are expected, or providing systemic protection for them) and as we see, those are outlawed in some WBF events.
This goes back to your "online convention" card thing with the 28 pages of notes about your system that you expect your opponents to look at during the 14 minutes you have to play 2 boards in an online tournment. Your explaination is that it is just a few "clicks" to find out what a specified bid means, but then it is a few more clicks to see what other inferences are drawn from this bid (as opposed to another), and of course the time to load the 28 page link, and hope that it doesn't swamp out the memory on your opponents computer and knock your opponent off line. That is unreasonable, and that is why for elite events where top teams are going to play extended matches against each other these things are allowed but only with EXTENSIVE PRIOR DISCLOSURE in the form of advance exchange of agreements in writing 3 months prior to the event, a 15 minute discuss time PRIOR to each session for review, and detailed TWO page notes of defense for use during the play.
Despite this, you seem to believe that on line bridge anything goes. It is a wild and wooly free for all. In FACT if you want to play by international "online laws", you might want to check out...rules for the "internet world bridge championship" from okbridge at http://blueclub.okbridge.com/iwbc2001/conv...strictions.php3
There was considerable limitiation: no opening bid at one level with less than 8 hcp, no psych of any conventional bid, no forcing pass, no encrypted signals, weak preempts without at least one definded suit (mullt 2D ok, hower), two-way opening bids which show either length or shortness in a suit, etc.
And before you jump on OKBridge being "american", note the language of their not psyching a convention call, which reads:
"Conventional opening bids which may be psyched. This rule bars the psyching of conventional opening bids (Laws of Duplicate Contract Bridge, Law 40D; interpretation of the WBF Laws Commission.). This does not prohibit minor deviations from conventional opening bids. " Quoting law 40-D from way above in this post.
#11
Posted 2003-November-24, 13:48
As you note, the WBF delgates authority over a wide variety of regulations to the appropriate Sponsoring Organization. In the case of physical events within North America, the Sponsoring Organization is normally either the ACBL or the USBF.
I have no problem with this approach. Nor do I object to individual sponsoring organizations establishing online games with clearly definied sets of regulations. For example, the ACBL has established its own online bridge site. This is fine by me. Equivalently, I see nothing wrong with players organizing tournaments on BBO that will be conducted using ACBL alerting regulations and convention charts.
However, I strenuously object to the assertion that the particular set of regulations that the ACBL/EBU/Whatever has adopted have any bearing on "online bridge" as a whole. Just as I believe that Sponsoring Organzations have the right to run its a tournaments using ACBL rules, I have an equal right to refuse to particpate in events that use this set of regulations.
Where the disconnect comes about is when Sponsoring Oranizations chose to run events without any clear guidance regarding the set of regulations that will be enforced. Personally, I see no reason why we should assume that ACBL or EBU standards should be the default. Both organizations are dying and will be nearly completely irrelevant to organizaed bridge within a decade.
BTW, for what its worth the WBF is pretty damn generous with its "invitations". Case in Point the WBF Championships in Montreal had a large number of events run under WBF laws open to anyone willing to fork over sufficient cash.
#12
Posted 2003-November-24, 14:02
It is interesting to compare the success that the Austrlian, Dutch, and Swedish Bridge Federations have running tournaments that permit a wide variety of high complex artifical methods during short round pair events. The main difference is that players are socialized to understand that variance in methods is an established part and parcel of the game.
For a variety of reasons, the ACBL has seen fit to try to lower bridge down to the lowest common denominator. In doing so, that have basically destoyed the game in North America. The ACBL continues to lumber on, however, the organization is about to fall off a cliff as its core membership becomes too old to continue.
The mean Age of ACBL members is 69
Each year the mean age increases by almost a year.
This is a sign of an organization in pathological decline t
#13
Posted 2003-November-24, 14:19
What they allow, and dont' allow, has always been a random crap shoot.I suspect based upon what people on the convention committee was familiar with (or maybe what they or their friends liked to play). In fact, I dropped out of competitive bridge for a long time, in part to make a living, in part because how could i win if the bidding systems/methods that made the most sense to me where not allowed. In addition, all but one of the 5 Romex players also took hiatus from the game (one has never stopped being tournment active). But even I have to agree that highly unusual methods that are, to use a term I don't like, distructive, must be limited. I have no idea why they banned (for a while) a foring but unbalanced 1NT, or why they banned mexican 2D showing a big balanced hand. But I can see why they might ban an opening 1H bid on 0 to 7 hcp.
Ben
#14
Posted 2003-November-24, 14:47
Quote
What they allow, and dont' allow, has always been a random crap shoot.I suspect based upon what people on the convention committee was familiar with (or maybe what they or their friends liked to play). In fact, I dropped out of competitive bridge for a long time, in part to make a living, in part because how could i win if the bidding systems/methods that made the most sense to me where not allowed. In addition, all but one of the 5 Romex players also took hiatus from the game (one has never stopped being tournment active). But even I have to agree that highly unusual methods that are, to use a term I don't like, distructive, must be limited. I have no idea why they banned (for a while) a foring but unbalanced 1NT, or why they banned mexican 2D showing a big balanced hand. But I can see why they might ban an opening 1H bid on 0 to 7 hcp.
Ben
They have to generate revenues, if you allow anything the game gets very complex since you have to teach beginners meta-defenses and how to prepare for the unexpected from start, this makes the learning curve of this game steeper finally resulting in less new players, and thus less revenues from tournaments and classes.
Meckstroth can open 1NT 10-12 and you are supossed to have a defense against that and the multiple run-outs that they have well studied. But you cannot open pass showing 13+. This is absurd since the mini-NT is more destructive and harder to defend than a forcing pass, a mini-NT can ruin your constructive bidding while "pass" can't. There're forcing pass systems without a fert and they are forbidden, the reason is a dark mistery and the only acceptable explanation is that someone decided they are evil.
I don't mind having destructive methods and conventions banned to make the game more popular and blah blah... but why? o why? why ban a system just because it is not "common" ? Playing against uncommon systems is a skill that bridge players must learn to develop without protection from organizations that don't want to bother about diversity.
#15
Posted 2003-November-24, 17:50
a gadget here or there over time but aren't interested in learning
any more because they have enough information to enjoy the
game. For less than 10% of us, system experimentation is part
of the enjoyment. Those of us in the 10% annoy everyone else
and are at the same time annoyed by the governing bodies who
seek to protect their income by trying to stop us experimenters
from driving everyone else away. Only in big venues is there
sufficient critical mass to have an event where you can gather
people who like to experiment with systems.
I tried to create such an environment on BBO with the fish out of
water tournaments but the current BBO infrastructure made this
too difficult. Even if the infrastructure supported what I was
trying to do, you basically need established partnerships to play
unusual systems and there wasn't enough of these online at any
time to have a tournament. Maybe...just maybe there might be
enough such people at a NABC. You can't make a system
experimentation session the only one available though because
people who just want to play will join the session not knowing
what they are getting into and they won't enjoy it and you just
created more people calling for a more permanent ban.
And I agree with Luis, nothing is difficult about defending a forcing
pass. Only people's lack of experience make it moderately troublesome.
1H fert (as in Tresboof) is designed to be preemptive and to get the
opponents out of their normal system. This is the goal of all
preemption so people must just not like the idea of preempting on
weak balanced hands! If preempting on weak balanced hands is so
inferior then let us play it against you and punish us for our insolence.
#16
Posted 2003-November-24, 22:23
Quote
With this said and done, the event organizers also have an obligation to to publish the conditions of contest.
...
As to your specific example: I am not aware of any Zonal authority that bans player's from psyching in first/second seat.
Psyches are specifically allowed by the laws of bridge.
Therefore I do not think that you can regulate psychic calls.
That applies in a general sense - you can regulate psyches of conventional calls.
Wayne
I believe that the USA currently hold only the World Championship For People Who Still Bid Like Your Auntie Gladys - dburn
dunno how to play 4 card majors - JLOGIC
True but I know Standard American and what better reason could I have for playing Precision? - Hideous Hog
Bidding is an estimation of probabilities SJ Simon
#17
Posted 2003-November-24, 22:32
(fert) 1N = 0-10 any
Fwiw FP systems are not permitted in matches of less than 14 boards in Aus, and systems need to be submitted a week in advance. You are expected to provide your own defence, though the written defence is allowed at the table. I much prefer this to the US system, where the some of the defences provided are really poor. (I wonder if deliberately so?).
Psyching strong openings is forbidden. Most other stuff is allowed even in 2 board pairs events, including transfer openings, canape bids, ALL sorts of weird and wonderful two bids, nt openings that may or may not contain a s/t systemically etc etc. People cope!
Agree totally with Luis, if you ban psyches, you might be playing some card game but you are not playing bridge.
Oh, and if anyone thinks psyching is "more often than not losing bridge", it isn't if done sensibly. The 1S opening Dwayne quotes is of a man demented. Try the odd sting cue in a slam auction and see if it loses.
#18
Posted 2003-November-26, 19:46
It's just ridiculous what people want to ban! In my region, psychics are allowed only once per tournament/club evening. Brown sticker conventions are only allowed in the 2 highest competitions, rule of 18 is about always active (so no 1X psychics),... No wonder no Belgian team gets far in international events. Everybody plays a standard system, even top teams.
And if you come up with a psych, opponents are mad because they feel like we lie about our system. A few weeks ago, my partner bid 2C after a 1H opening from me with 2 Clubs and 4 Diamonds. His hand came on the table, and ops were complaining that I should alert his bid, while I only know that p has 4+C... They almost went crazy about it, and I actually didn't see the purpose of his psyche.
A psych that I did a few times (the one with p-p-1NT) crazed some opponents to, but now we've adopted it in our system
Anyway, about playing online: ACBL isn't the standard, because I (and many many many other players) don't know their rules. It's not because many players are Americans that their rules are used. So if it's not written in the conditions of contest, it's allowed. Organizers don't have the right to change the rules during an event. If they forget to put it in te conditions of contest, too bad!
But I've experienced that you have to let partner know that you dare to psych, because otherwise they kick you in crazy contracts. First time I played with Misho ( 8) the bluff-master 8) ) we got several bottoms because of psychics. Then he just told me that when I've passed he dares to bluff a lot, and it went a lot better
#19
Posted 2003-November-26, 20:12
Quote
Maybe you might want to read the World Bridge Federations, "Dode of Laws for Electronic Bridge" http://www.ecatsbridge.com/BiB/b7/online_l...aws/default.asp
BtW, a number of your pyches are brown sticker and illegal in civilized bridge (only Category I events allow them and even then only after extensive documentation to opponents before and with written suggested defense... to spring this on line against the unsuspected is, well, not sporting. And in my saying this, please remember I greatly favor pscyhes... just controlled psyches with chekbacks without proper documentation and alerting, in an online envronment I don't like). The 3rd seat psych control for the 2NT openign bid for instance.
Ben
#20
Posted 2003-November-27, 19:56
Going back to the original point, there are Sponsoring organizations - Austria, I know, I think South Africa has something like it - where psyches in first and second seat are illegal. The consensus of the BLML is that the regulation is illegal, but nobody's going to complain about it.
It may have been that the pair who complained were Austrians (or usually played in clubs where that regulation was also in effect).
My own psyching frequency has gone down significantly since I started directing regularly at the club I usually play at...I think it would probably be okay by now (my ethical reputation has been made for better or worse), but I haven't had the hand for it the last little while (or I've been second hand, red on white, and decided not to!)
Having said that, I guess that the "good" intermediates (novices working hard and doing well at it) had better watch out. Yes, I know it's losing bridge to psych against C players, but the two or three pairs I'm thinking of will appreciate the education (especially if I crapout!)
Michael.

Help
