jdonn, on Jun 19 2006, 07:19 AM, said:
cphastrup, on Jun 18 2006, 11:25 PM, said:
jdonn, on Jun 18 2006, 11:10 PM, said:
You must be mixing up the two red cards (Which were both direct red as far as I can tell from the highlights). The first red card I can't see why anyone would dispute. Spikes down? You must thinking about the second red card, which is maybe more "orange", but it's still a reckless, risky challenge from behind.
2 minutes of higlights - including the red cards:
http://youtube.com/w...rch=usa%20italy
Edit: The second one was a yellow-red, according to the match reports. So now I can't disagree with any of the red cards at all.
Thanks for the clip.
I feel like I have woken up in Bizarro world where the whole world but me has gone mad. The first was a yellow, though not even an eggregious one, it is miles from a red card. It is so far from red that I can't for the life of me even believe anyone is disputing that. The second was more eggregious but still a yellow as far as I'm concerned, though the point is moot since I accept that the second was given as a yellow/red, which was the correct call.
Yellow cards are the normal call for hard tackles that are late or from behind. Red cards are for elbows to the head, late slide tackles with the spikes up that are intended to injure, things like that. These were just hard, late, bad tackles, completely normal yellow cards.
Mike, soccer is just not a big deal here to most people. I could say all the same things about almost any sport in most countries, like say basketball in England. It would be like criticizing our national table tennis team in the same way. But you share the same quality as almost all sports fans, which is thinking the coaches and administrators do a lousy job. And I suppose I also share that quality as regards the referees
Sorry Josh, the first was a clear red card. Sliding with both feet straight ahead into the opponent from behind has been a guarantueed red card for quite some time. There is no chance to prevent a foul, and it's extremely likely to cause injuries. (Even if you succeed with the tackle, i.e. aren't late, you might still get a free-kick and a yellow card for dangerous play.)
I admit the red card for Italy would have been worth sending the whole team off, preferably for all the matches.
Arend

Help
