the saint, on Jun 26 2006, 07:27 PM, said:
You lot actually awake when it comes to all this red card stuff? I've told you all before that its FIFAs fault clamping down on all the wrong things. Instead of allowing a certain amount of physicality and cutting out all the cheating (some teams are much worse than others, but as this is a multi-national board, I won't shame which ones cheat their way to victory as their first course of action because it will only rile people).
To be honest I'd like to hear the names from you. You have made quite a few well-informed comments so far, why should anybody blame you for dropping a few names. When in doubt, people will assume anyway that it's just out of frustration about the English performance ;-).
I agree with what you have said about a good ref policy so far. Too many yellows are shown for acceptable tackles. On the other hand, some really annoying stuff (like dress tucking) has almost vanished due to the hard line the refs are going about this. So the situation is not completely hopeless.
No, what I find the most annoying are the fussy offside decisions. 1 out of 3 offsides are actual equal height situations decided in favor of the defending team (actually they should be made in favor of the advancing team, according to official policy). This is so damn frustrating. Beautiful advances are stopped because the linesman imagines an offside. One of my friends has suggested to bring in two additional linesmen and only give a freekick if both of them see an offside. Maybe this would work, anyways something has to be done.
I also agree with what you have said quite in the beginning of this thread about the general quality of the refs: having only Champions League refs would be a lot better. Just for the sake of internationalism the FIFA is bringing in too many inexperienced referees from countries without high class tournaments/leagues.
Quote
As a result, you only have to breath on someone to get booked and it has turned into a diving competition to see who can get the most opponents sent off. To encourage free flowing football, you have to allow challenges to be made. All this stop-start nonsense has stifled games. Players must also be banned immediately from harassing the referees. It is ugly and unsportsmanlike - witness Podolski's patting the ref on the back for sending off Lucic. There is no place for that.
Podolski is young and inexperienced, and I also think he's not the brightest. Probably refs don't take it even seriously if such players do that. In principle you are right, of course, but I think there are worse offenses.
A good referee will get so much respect that the players won't even dare patronizing or harassment (cf. Collina).
--Sigi