BBO Discussion Forums: New "Fish out of water" tournament series. - BBO Discussion Forums

Jump to content

Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

New "Fish out of water" tournament series.

#1 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-19, 20:32

Now that I have my first tourney directorship under my belt, you'll
soon start seeing a series of tournaments hosted by me entitled
"Fish out of water." Fish out of water tourneys are devoted to
the systems enthusiasts among us. The following rules apply in
fish out of water tourneys:

1. SAYC and 2/1 systems are NOT ALLOWED.
2. No player can play the predominant system in his country of
residence.
3. Posted convention cards are mandatory. Director(s) will be
actively checking.
4. Be proactive about alerting. It is a good idea to alert all
non-natural bids.

For those who obey the rules, you'll win points that accumulate.
Not only will I track the points and post them on a web site but
I'll post average player performance on the web site.

Todd
0

#2 User is offline   mishovnbg 

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Full Members
  • Posts: 769
  • Joined: 2003-February-14
  • Location:Bulgaria, Varna
  • Interests:Bridge - new bidding systems, psyches; Computers - education, service, program; Computer games great fan :-)

Posted 2003-September-22, 06:15

Hi!
Before to organize tournaments, may be is good idea to read some literature about directors job and may be to pass some tests? With wrong decisions at tables you will accumulate wrong points...
I will lecture here, but duty of director is not to judge about possible result of deal, if some of contestants played too slow. In same case he must penalize slow contestant and compensate normal one. Reason of slow play is no interesting - slow bidding, slow play, go to toilet, bad connection... It is clear at least that contestant who was NOT FAULT can not be penalized!!!
Normal practice here is to ajust score to 60%-40% in MP event or average result in session if it is more than 60%. For IMP event in BBO regular practice is ave+/- = 3 IMP.
Misho
MishoVnBg
0

#3 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-22, 11:33

Your opponent had connection problems and did not play slow
once connectivity was restored. There was no obvious bridge
result to assign and since NO ONE was at fault, I assigned
ave==. If declarer played slow and defenders didn't then I
would probably give ave-+. However, I tried to generate the
fairest result possible for both pairs. I guess you weren't
satisfied with our conversation after I awarded ave== and so
you bring this here for what purpose? To try to defame me?

How about this simple rule...if you don't like my belief that
connection problems should usually result in ave== then don't
play in any more of my tournaments.
0

#4 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-22, 11:39

On a happier note, the Fish out of water website is up at
http://www.geocities.com/DrTodd13/fish-out...t-of-water.html.
Results of the first tourney are available there along with
the current conditions of contest. More info below.

The first fish out of water tournament makes things perfectly
clear. People sign up for tourneys without even reading the
tournament description. Moreover, those who read it often
choose to ignore it. How much simpler could "No SAYC allowed"
be? Of course, I'll give those from other countries a break who
can't read English but all these things force me to do things a
little differently. From now on, if you want to participate in
this tournament series, just send me an e-mail or message on
BBO letting me know you'd like to be able to participate and
I'll add you to the FOOW private club. Only members of this
club will be allowed to join future FOOW tournaments.

Most weekend days probably around 10am PST there will be
a fish out of water tournament. I'll try to post the tournament a
couple days in advance so people can get their favorite partners
and plan.

DrTodd
0

#5 User is offline   mishovnbg 

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Full Members
  • Posts: 769
  • Joined: 2003-February-14
  • Location:Bulgaria, Varna
  • Interests:Bridge - new bidding systems, psyches; Computers - education, service, program; Computer games great fan :-)

Posted 2003-September-22, 22:04

Ty for reply, I will not play there more ofcourse :)
Misho
MishoVnBg
0

#6 User is offline   Gerardo 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 2,525
  • Joined: 2003-February-12
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Dartmouth, NS, Canada

Posted 2003-September-22, 23:09

Reviewing the rules (which I am no expert of, please correect if wrong)

A- implies party is at fault
A implies party is partially at fault
A+ implies party not at fault.

So, if no one is at fault, it should be A++. :)

Now, I personally assign A- on conn problems, but I can see good reasons to assign A= on them; however, I think the other pair should get nothing short of A+. I don't think it is A++ though, if not your fault, your conn is your responsability, IMHO.

In fact, I may start to apply A+= and A=+ instead of A+- and A-+, it may be fairer. I'll move this topic to a new thread and start a poll on it.

#7 User is offline   hrothgar 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 15,725
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Natick, MA
  • Interests:Travel
    Cooking
    Brewing
    Hiking

Posted 2003-September-22, 23:35

I fail to see what is so complicated here.
What is wrong with just cancelling the board for the pairs in question?
Alternatively, just assign them their session score absent the spoiled board?

This seems to be the best way to ensure that the spoiled board does not effect the pairs results.
Alderaan delenda est
0

#8 User is offline   mishovnbg 

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Full Members
  • Posts: 769
  • Joined: 2003-February-14
  • Location:Bulgaria, Varna
  • Interests:Bridge - new bidding systems, psyches; Computers - education, service, program; Computer games great fan :-)

Posted 2003-September-23, 07:39

Quote


I fail to see what is so complicated here.
What is wrong with just cancelling the board for the pairs in question?
Alternatively, just assign them their session score absent the spoiled board?

This seems to be the best way to ensure that the spoiled board does not effect the pairs results.


Hi Richard!

The problem is director must not think like player - often mistake for beginner directors. He cant understand, as a director he MUST use regulations (supposing he know them) and cant judge by own opinion in cases where law can be applyed directly.
In my case (interesting only as directors problem, I cant win this tourney anyway) opponents played slow, because they had connection problems. I called director on time, but we still could not finish board. I am contestant and I was not guilty! Main rule is to not penalise not guilty contestant!
For 2 such boards MR Todd penalty me one time with ave= and one with ave-??? Ave= is penalty for me because my result from all tourney was above average.
I thought it was mistake of begiiner director... But after MR Todds unfriendly replay I doubt his sincerity :).
Misho
MishoVnBg
0

#9 User is offline   hrothgar 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 15,725
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Natick, MA
  • Interests:Travel
    Cooking
    Brewing
    Hiking

Posted 2003-September-23, 09:11

Misho, you are missing the point of my post.

With one notable exception, ANY adjustment that the director makes is going to distort your results in this event. I don't care if the director assigns you an A=, an A+, or and A- this is causing a non-bridge result to impact your score.

All I am saying is that the most equitable way to handle this incident is to either cancel the board outright or assign the session score. Please explain why using some fixed value such as an A+ for each side creates less of a distortion.
Alderaan delenda est
0

#10 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-23, 09:55

Quote

Misho, you are missing the point of my post.

With one notable exception, ANY adjustment that the director makes is going to distort your results in this event. I don't care if the director assigns you an A=, an A+, or and A- this is causing a non-bridge result to impact your score.

All I am saying is that the most equitable way to handle this incident is to either cancel the board outright or assign the session score. Please explain why using some fixed value such as an A+ for each side creates less of a distortion.


Let's put the problem forward with a concrete example you may recongnize. :-) Let's assume it is the second board of a two board set, and your partner made a 1H psychic overcall vul and you hold:
S - A10xxx
H - AQ10x
D - xx
C - xx

And, you of course, make a nice fit jump in spades landing you into a 4Sx contract that not a single pair came close to finding 4S's. Now you are going to win a bushel of imps (let say 8 ). If slow play happens on this board, caused by your opponents, and you get an average (0 imps how do you feel)? Or, lets say you just throw this out (so you get the average of your overall event, which I doubt is anywhere near the +8 imps per board, and if it is, you win anyway). Even if you get +3 imps, you are down five towards what you could have earned.

On the other hand, let's say the tournment director comes along and says, sorry about the slow play, so I award NS-4Sx making 4 (which it can make), but is that fair if there are lines of play declearer might choose that can go down? If 4S goes down one instead of winning 8 imps, say you lose 10 imps. EW might rightfully suggest that they are due 10 imps or at least an averge plus, and certainly not an average minus.

This hand, as you well know, happened as described, and the one declearer in 4Sx went down one (I think we can agree it probably should have made). How should this hand be handled if slow play had occured caused by EW? What if caused by NS? There are 18 imps on the table for someone to win/lose.

I think this is where the problem arises. I guess if at the end there is NO WAY to go down, or NO WAY to make, maybe the score should be credited as making or down (no harm in that I guess, but others will clearly disagree). But given the number of imps at stake, and average or a throw out the hand, is likely very bad. I think awarding AVERAGE + for the non-offending side (in short games, I would make average + 4 imps, due to the size of "wins") and either AVERAGE or AVERAGE minus to the offending side seems just about right, as it is at least a consistent policy. But I would be a little wary of a blanket, let the director decide what would have happened if the hand had been played out. Under those rules, I would have been forced to award 4Sx= on this hand and 8 imps for NS, when the actual result when played turned out to be 4Sx-1, and -10 imps for them.

BTW, in lastnights abalucy event, 16 boards, the winners averaged just 2.4 imps per hand, so even an "average plus" of 3 imps would probably be better than most peoples "session average".

Ben
--Ben--

#11 User is offline   hrothgar 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 15,725
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Natick, MA
  • Interests:Travel
    Cooking
    Brewing
    Hiking

Posted 2003-September-23, 10:39

First comment: I should have played on Diamonds and made 4SX
Second comment: At least I can't be accused of fielding the psyche :-)

Third comment: You are introducing a new element to the argument.

The original discussion contained a very specific data point. The player who was responsible for the slow play which resulted in the board being fouled lost their connection to BBO. The director used this piece of information and decided that that the slow play was due to the whims of the Internet gods rather than any kind of infraction on the part of a specific pair. Accordingly, I suggested a corresponding scoring solution.

You are introducing two new and complex adjustments to this problem.

First, you are assuming cases in which one particular pair is to blame for the slow play. Furthermore you assume that the director is in a position to establish this.

Second, you assume that it is possible to determine what "SHOULD" happen on a given board. As this example shows, even if a pair bids to a making contract, a poor line of play may allow it to make. Alternatively, even if a pair SHOULD go down, poor defense might let the result through.

I think that it is better to avoid as much complexity as possible.
I would prefer blanket rules to deal with this type of exception even if they occasional create sub-optimal results.

Case in point: Suppose that 51 out of the 52 cards have been played.
Furthermore, assume that the player who is left to play has lost his/her connection to BBO. I would prefer to see the board cancelled for both pairs rather than allowing the director to apply his judgement regarding the most likely result.

Do I believe that the director would ahve rule correctly in this case?
Yes I do.

However, I also believe that allow this type of dicretion creates a "slippery slope". It becomes almost impossible to draw a logical line in the sand dictating when the director is qualified to reach this type of conclusion. I prefer an asolute rule, that can be apply clearly and uniformly rather than trusting in the whims of individual judgement.
Alderaan delenda est
0

#12 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-23, 11:16

I strive toward equity. I don't think that blanket rules can
restore equity and the laws of bridge recognize that as such
in that equity adjustments can be made at director's discretion
above and beyond the penalty for some infraction.

Let us say I'm directing and watching a table and see a pair
bid to a crazy slam and then declarer play very slow trying
to make it only to be down 2 with 3 tricks left. A+ for non-slow
players is not sufficient reward and A- an insufficient penalty.
Even if the result is still not certain, I think an adjusted score
of -2 or -3 are both better than A+. If I wasn't watching the
play and people at the table do not agree who played slow
then A-- for each pair it is. The tricky case is defenders played
slow but declarer still in a ridiculous contract. What is the
right award in this case? A- for declarer because the slam is
ridiculous and A= for defenders to punish them for slow play?
0

#13 User is offline   inquiry 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Admin
  • Posts: 14,566
  • Joined: 2003-February-13
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Amelia Island, FL
  • Interests:Bridge, what else?

Posted 2003-September-23, 11:28

Richard,

My assumption is that "lost connectivity" equates to being responsible for slow play. That is, if someone loses their connection then they are responsible, through no "fault of their own", but so be it. I played in an event with malucy once when his cable modem went out after the third board. It was a 14 board MP event BEFORE substitutes were allowed. We got 11 average minuses (45%), and funny, we still ended up above average. Now imagine if those were all thrown out or given the result of the other hands? We would have won in a run away (not possible today, of course).

I think the "penatly" as it is, has to be if you can identify a culprit (even disconnect), to award average plus, and either average minus or average depending upon the nature of the "crime". So, I don't see myself introducing a third element, I think. Disconnect is responsible for slow play. If slow play can't be assessed to one or other, average and move on, but disconnect gets treated same as clearly slow play (after all, getting a bad board, disconnnect your modem...whalla, disconnect... come back a few minutes later, horrible result turned to average under DrTodd rules).

Now as for your stating about trying to determine what would have happened. I am against that other than in very extreme circumstances. Someone claiming and the claim is correct but not accepted (say 3 tricks to go, holding last three trumps, anytime on last trick, or with one card left to the NEXT to last trick, or with two cards left to the last two tricks, neither or which can affect the outcome, or no way for one side to possible gain or lose what is obvious to all a trick (one has KQJT of trumps in four card ending with other side having the trump ace, something obvious like that). I gave the example hand to illustrate the point that while I thought 4Sx would always make, and if FORCED to rule, I might have ruled that it did, the fact is I think that would be a horrible solution... my specific quote was "I guess if at the end there is NO WAY to go down, or NO WAY to make, maybe the score should be credited as making or down (no harm in that I guess, but others will clearly disagree)."

So I think we are very close to the same position, when you said "I prefer an asolute rule, that can be apply clearly and uniformly rather than trusting in the whims of individual judgement." I agree. I favor, average + for none offending side, average minus for offending side (disconnect and poor connection are offending IMHO). And averages (0 imps or 50%) if not clear why slow play occurred. One of your solution (throw board out) at imps is the same as 0 imps, at MP and imps, however, your solution of session average can have a huge effect. Take my example above where with that rule, mike and I would have won. Anyone else, having a few good boards early, and then play slow seems to be the road to victory. Imagine a ten board event, and you are up 16 imps after four boards. Playing slow so as not to finish gains you four imps for each of the next six boards, let someone try to catch your 40 imps. Exaggerated, yes, gonna happen? Not as described, but therein is the problem with the second solution.

Ben

PS, I don't really feel strongly about this issue. All I ask is that a) the rules be spelled out, B) people who "gimmick" the event to take account of loopholes in the rules be eventually caught and banned, and c) we just have fun. I think EACH director who goes to all the trouble to run these events for us should get to set their own rules without being seconded guessed. If you don't like the rules, find a different tournment to play in. :-)
--Ben--

#14 User is offline   DrTodd13 

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Advanced Members
  • Posts: 1,156
  • Joined: 2003-July-03
  • Location:Portland, Oregon

Posted 2003-September-23, 14:52

It is true Ben that under my current rules when I direct, is that if you are
heading for a disaster and intentionally disconnect yourself that you gain
under my approach. However, you also gain under your proposal of ave-.
The difference is only 3 or 4 IMPs. We have the same problem either way
and the people that do this need to be caught.

There is no incentive to be delayed so long that you get replaced and to
avoid a bad board that way. Only incentive would be if you could pretend
to be disconnected then to come back before you get replaced. Maybe the
system could somehow track how often people fail to finish boards and the
worst offenders could be paid special attention to or at a minimum someone
in a kind way offer to help them get a more reliable connection. Bad offenders
whether intentionally or by having a bad ISP could be asked not to play in
(clocked) tourneys.
0

#15 User is offline   mishovnbg 

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • Group: Full Members
  • Posts: 769
  • Joined: 2003-February-14
  • Location:Bulgaria, Varna
  • Interests:Bridge - new bidding systems, psyches; Computers - education, service, program; Computer games great fan :-)

Posted 2003-September-23, 18:38

Quote

All I am saying is that the most equitable way to handle this incident is to either cancel the board outright or assign the session score. Please explain why using some fixed value such as an A+ for each side creates less of a distortion.


Hi Richard!
I am not author of bridge regulations, I just know them and use them! Rule: if board cant be complete director must judge administrative result. Dependig of type of tournament not guilty contestant receive ave+ result ( 60%- MP, 3 - IMP ), while guilty one ave- ( 40% MP, -3 - IMP). It is possible to have 60%-60%(both not guilty) or 40%-40%(both guilty). If actual result of not guilty contestant is above 60% (3 IMP) director must ajust all to his actual result. Director cant judge about unfinished deal and possible result IF it was finished!!! Even about crazy one! As I wrote in previous post - typical directors mistake.
Exceptions? Very rare in case of play at table - director can give additional seconds for finishing several tricks or accept claim.
Online bridge? Depend of software available for directors. With right monitoring program will be very easy to judge trivial cases, like slow play - computer is best witness!

Hi Ben!
Not a perfect world, not a perfect people, not a perfect bridge regulations, not a perfect directors... But may be if all is perfect will be very tediously to live friend B).
Any rule can be avoided... Bridge law exist to penalyze unintentional mistakes, not one or other type of cheating... For cheaters exist police, in BBO yellows. I know they are volunteers, like directors by the way. We dont pay, so we cant ask from them too much except basics. But basic they must do!!! Else why they are volunteers for this job?

Misho
MishoVnBg
0

Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

1 User(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users